Oxygen Is Not The Limit: Diversity And Metabolic Potential Of Globally Distributed Endosymbionts
Illustration of the initially discovered endosymbiont ‘Candidatus Azoamicus ciliaticola’ and its ciliate host. The figure is a composite of a scanning electron microscope image (SEM, grey) and fluorescence images. Visible is the endosymbiont (yellow) and bacterial prey in food vacuoles as well as the large cell nucleus (blue). The outer structure of the weakly fluorescent ciliate as well as the cilia are also visible. Credit S. Ahmerkamp/Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology
In 2021, scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology in Bremen, Germany, reported an astonishing new form of symbiosis: They found a unique bacterium that lives inside a ciliate – a unicellular eukaryote – and provides it with energy. The symbiont’s role is thus strongly reminiscent of mitochondria, with the key difference that the endosymbiont derives energy from the respiration of nitrate, not oxygen.
Now the researchers from Bremen set out to learn more about the environmental distribution and diversity of these peculiar symbionts. “After our initial discovery of this symbiont in a freshwater lake, we wondered how common these organisms are in nature”, says Jana Milucka from the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology. “Are they extremely rare and therefore eluded detection so long? Or do they exist elsewhere and if so, what are their metabolic capacities?”
A global inhabitant
The scientists set out to look for molecular signatures of the symbiont in huge public sequencing databases, which contain vast amounts of genetic data from all kinds of environmental samples. And indeed, they detected these symbionts in about 1000 different datasets. “. We were surprised how ubiquitous they are. We could find them on every inhabited continent”, says Milucka. “Moreover, we learned that they can live not only in lakes and other freshwater habitats but also in groundwater and even wastewater.”
Meet the family: New members do new tricks
The scientists discovered not only the original symbiont in these datasets, but also some new close relatives. “We ended up identifying four new species, two of which actually constituted a new genus. Because this new genus of symbionts likely has a similar role as the originally discovered Azoamicus (name meaning “nitrogen friend”), we named the new genus Azosocius (“nitrogen associate”), explains first-author Daan Speth. “Lucky for us, one of the new Azosocius species was retrieved not too far from Bremen, from a groundwater sample in Hainich, Germany.”
Now the scientists wanted to dig deeper into the life of these new species. Thanks to a collaboration with Kirsten Küsel and Will Overholt from the Friedrich Schiller University in Jena, Germany, who initially collected the Hainich samples, they were able to access the sampling site and look into metatranscriptomic data, i.e. data describing the gene expression in the sample and indicating microbial activity. “Here, we were in for another surprise – these respiratory symbionts can do new tricks”, Speth continues. Unlike the original symbiont species, which can only perform anaerobic respiration (i.e. denitrification), all new symbiont species actually encode a terminal oxidase – an enzyme that enables them to also respire oxygen in addition to nitrogen. “This can explain why we find these symbionts also in environments that are fully or partially oxic.”
Differential gene loss in Azoamicaceae genomes. Circular genome maps of Azoamicus (a) and Azosocius (b) genomes, with rings (inside to outside) indi- cating GC skew, GC content, reverse strand genes, forward strand genes. rRNA and tRNA genes are indicated in black, protein coding genes encoded in multiple genomes of a genus are indicated in gray. Protein coding genes differentially lost in Azoamicus are indicated in pink, and differentially lost in Azosocius in orange. The cytochrome cbb3 oxidase and associated genes are highlighted in blue, and the ATP/ADP transporter tlcA genes in purple. — Nature Communications
Evolutionary and ecological implications
These results, now presented in the journal Nature Communications, answer the scientists’ open questions regarding the symbiont’s biogeography. “Thanks to the discovery of these new species, we can now also start thinking more about their evolution”, Milucka looks ahead. “We can hopefully understand better how these beneficial symbioses begin and how they evolve over time.“ Moreover, there is an ecological aspect to this research: “By performing denitrification, this symbiosis impacts the nitrogen cycle of their respective habitat and has the potential to remove nutrients, such as nitrogen oxides, as well as produce greenhouse gases, such as nitrous oxide”, adds Speth.
And last but not least, there is the simple appreciation of the intriguing world of microbes. “This organism is a marvel of nature”, Milucka enthuses. “Protists are capable of such astonishing metabolic innovations, often because they so readily jump into relationships with prokaryotes. To me, this is just fascinating. When it comes to understanding the evolution of eukaryotes, these organisms are an important piece of the puzzle.”
Gene distribution and pathway overview in the Azoamicaceae genomes. a UpSet plot showing the coding sequence (CDS) content shared between, or unique to, the individual Azoamicaceae genomes. Each vertical bar represents the number of genes in an intersecting set between the genomes. The filled circles connected by lines indicate which genomes contribute genes to the intersecting set. Sets are ordered by the number of genomes contributing, and then the number of genes in the set. Vertical bars are colored according to the broad classification of genes that can be found in Supplementary Data 2. Total coding sequence numbers for the genomes are Ca. A aquiferis 352; Ca. A agrarius 347; Ca. A soli 299; Ca. A ciliaticola 311; Ca. A viridis 378 (b, inset) Distribution of the gene content shown in panel A, summarized by genus. Aa: Azoamicus, As: Azosocius. (c, inset) Distribution of the CDS content shown in panel A summarized by the number of genomes containing each gene. (d) Key pathways in the Azoamicaceae genomes that could enable generation of ATP for the host cell from both denitrification and aerobic respiration. Boxes indicate protein complexes or pathways, with background shading corresponding to the categories in panels (a–c). Filled and empty circles indicate the presence/absence of a complex or pathway in the genome. Roman numerals in the boxes representing the electron transport chain complexes indi- cate: (I) NADH dehydrogenase, (II) succinate dehydrogenase, (III) bc1 complex, (IV) cytochrome cbb3 oxidase, (V) ATP synthase. — Nature Communications
Genetic potential for aerobic respiration and denitrification in globally distributed respiratory endosymbionts, Nature Communications (open access)
Astrobiology