The Emirates Stadium, a cauldron of anticipation before kick-off, fell into a stunned silence as the final whistle confirmed a goalless draw between Arsenal and Everton. For Arsenal, a team harbouring genuine title aspirations, this result felt like a defeat. It was a stark reminder that even the most meticulously crafted tactical plans can falter against a well-drilled, defensively resolute opponent. This match, more than just a dropped point, has sparked a debate: is Mikel Arteta’s tactical approach, a blueprint for their impressive rise, now in need of evolution?
Arteta, since his arrival, has instilled a clear philosophy at Arsenal: possession-based football with an emphasis on quick, intricate passing and fluid attacking movements. This approach has yielded impressive results, transforming Arsenal from a mid-table team to a genuine title contender. However, the draw against Everton, Sean Dyche’s 500th league game as a manager, exposed a potential vulnerability in Arteta’s system: a lack of flexibility when faced with a deep-lying, compact defence.
Everton, under Dyche, executed their game plan to perfection. They sat deep, absorbed pressure, and denied Arsenal the space to weave their intricate passing patterns. The Gunners, accustomed to dictating the tempo and controlling possession, found themselves frustrated. Their passing lacked its usual penetration, and their movement, often so dynamic and unpredictable, became predictable and stagnant.
Mikel Arteta - English Premier League 2024-25 Data, Stats, Analysis and Scout report
This tactical impasse was most evident in Arsenal’s midfield. The usually dynamic trio of Martin Ødegaard, Declan Rice, and Mikel Merino struggled to exert their influence. Everton’s midfield, anchored by the veteran presence of Idrissa Gueye and Abdoulaye Doucoure, pressed aggressively, disrupting Arsenal’s build-up play and forcing hurried passes. This stifling of Arsenal’s midfield engine effectively nullified their attacking threat, leaving them toothless in the final third.
Mikel Arteta - English Premier League 2024-25 Data, Stats, Analysis and Scout report
While Everton’s defensive resilience deserves credit, Arsenal’s inability to break them down raises questions about their tactical adaptability. They appeared bereft of ideas when faced with a low block, resorting to aimless crosses into the box that were comfortably dealt with by Everton’s towering centre-backs. The lack of a Plan B, an alternative approach to unlock stubborn defences, is a worrying sign for a team with title ambitions.
This tactical rigidity is not a new phenomenon for Arsenal. Last season, they faced similar struggles against teams that sat deep and defended in numbers. The inability to overcome these defensive hurdles ultimately cost them crucial points, derailing their title challenge.
The question, then, is whether Arteta is willing to evolve his tactical approach. Does he possess the flexibility to adapt to different opponents and situations, to move away from his preferred possession-based style when circumstances demand it?
Mikel Arteta - English Premier League 2024-25 Data, Stats, Analysis and Scout report
There are signs that Arteta is aware of this tactical limitation and is actively seeking solutions. In recent games, he has experimented with different formations, and personnel, attempting to add more directness and penetration to their attack. The introduction of Leandro Trossard, a versatile forward with a knack for creating chances, and the reintegration of Ethan Nwaneri, a young midfielder with an eye for goal, are indications of Arteta’s willingness to tweak his system.
However, these tactical adjustments are still in their nascent stages. Whether they will prove sufficient to overcome well-drilled defensive units remains to be seen. The draw against Everton has underlined the urgency for Arteta to find the right balance between his possession-based philosophy and a more pragmatic approach.
Ultimately, the success of Arteta’s tactical evolution will depend on several factors:
Squad depth: Arsenal’s squad, while improved, still lacks the depth and quality to compete on multiple fronts.
Tactical flexibility: Arteta needs to demonstrate a willingness to adapt his approach, to incorporate elements of directness and counter-attacking football, especially against teams that sit deep.
The title race is a marathon, not a sprint, and there is still ample time for Arsenal to learn from their mistakes and refine their approach. However, the draw against Everton is a wake-up call, a stark reminder that tactical evolution is essential if they want to transform their potential into tangible silverware. The coming weeks will reveal whether Arteta can successfully navigate this tactical tightrope and guide Arsenal to their first Premier League title in almost two decades.
Visuals via TFA data viz engine