Everton director of football Kevin Thelwell speaks to Everton owner Farhad Moshiri at the London Stadium on January 21, 2023
Everton director of football Kevin Thelwell speaks to Everton owner Farhad Moshiri at the London Stadium on January 21, 2023
Everton are hoping that the takeover by the Friedkin Group provides them with a much-needed shot in the arm when it comes to being able to flex their muscles in the transfer market again after being forced to drastically scale back their spending over the past couple of years under Farhad Moshiri. In one of his typically bizarre chats with pal Jim White on talkSPORT, back in January 2023, Moshiri stated that: “I put my money where my mouth is and that is the most that an owner can do and I’ve done that.”
During the interview, the strains of Queen song Another One Bites the Dust ominously blared out in the background as the Monaco-based businessman reiterated he had a lot of faith in manager Frank Lampard, and insisted the struggling Blues boss would “get it right.” Two games and 11 days later, he’d be sacked.
Moshiri had indeed bankrolled an unprecedented level of spending at Everton but with a woeful lack of a coherent strategy and a repeated meddling in the football side of the operation, no team had squandered such a fortune to become so bad, as he had acknowledged with his “we have not always spent large amounts of money,” apology to the supporters the previous summer.
Related Articles
The six faces in the Everton directors' box after Dan Friedkin takeover and year of changing power
Everton summer signing earns high praise and respect of team-mates and manager
The first of the club’s unprecedented two points deductions in a single season for separate PSR charges would drop before the calendar year was out, prompting ECHO columnist Michael Ball to lament “Only Everton could have a billionaire accountant own them and get done on financial breaches!”
Before all of that, Moshiri, on striking a proposed takeover deal with 777 Partners, told loyal but long-suffering Evertonians in September 2023: “I believe they are the best partners to take our great club forward.” While TFG have finally ended the 69-year-old’s chaotic ownership, the transfer of power to custodians that Blues are praying should be a far safer pair of hands seems more luck than judgement on his part.
The solitary but far from insignificant positive legacy of Moshiri’s reign has been, by hook or by crook, getting the new stadium built at Bramley-Moore Dock, but when it came to footballing matters, he remained defiant and seemingly deluded to the end, claiming he left Everton in “a better place,” and proclaiming: “We brought top-class managers like Carlo Ancelotti to the club and who knows where we might have been had he not been lured back to his first love Real Madrid.”
Really? The legendary Italian has subsequently won a couple more Champions League titles at the Bernabeu, working in his natural habitat of massaging Galacticos’ egos, but he was an expensive and ineffective fish out of water during his mostly covid-induced behind closed doors stint by the Mersey.
His only full season in charge saw the team slump from being second in the table on Boxing Day to finish 10th and miss out on their goal of European qualification in a campaign that saw wins at Liverpool and Arsenal but also 10 home defeats. If he was anyone other than Ancelotti with his glittering CV, then serious questions would have been asked, but with the points deductions on the horizon and the budget slashed, the writing was on the wall.
Just look at how frugally Everton have been forced to cut their cloth in recent times after Moshiri cut his ties with long-standing business associate Alisher Usmanov and decided he wanted to sell up. Based on calculations by transfermarkt, since the start of 2020/21, Everton are the only club currently in the Premier League to have made a trading profit on players, with a figure of £27.25million in the black.
In contrast, their last opponents Chelsea, who they held to a goalless draw at Goodison Park on Sunday, have a net spend of £768.4m. Over that same period, a further 13 Premier League clubs have nine-figure net spends of £100m or much more.
Since 2022/23, the first window that current director of football Kevin Thelwell came in, Everton have made the biggest trading profit (£79.89m), with Leicester City the only other current Premier League club in the black (£35.06m) and Chelsea again leading the way in terms of net spend on £641.14m as one of a dozen clubs to have a £100m plus outlay.
Everton have not spent more than they received in a transfer window since the summer of 2022 and that window included the acquisition of Amadou Onana, who was later sold for a profit to Aston Villa; James Garner, now valued significantly higher than the fee paid to Manchester United, and Dwight McNeil, who has also been a key performer. In the period since 2022/23, the Blues have only spent significant fees on players aged 25 or under and have also been reliant on loan transfers and free transfers to avoid paying additional fees, and loans, having recruited four loan players this summer – more than any other Premier League club.
Total player costs have been reduced by around 8% (approximately £10m) since 2021/22 and this has been achieved by moving on many older, high-earning players, some of whom had poor availability records. Since 2022, Everton have also generated around £220m in transfer fees, including approximately £70m for ex-academy players, including Anthony Gordon, Lewis Dobbin, Ellis Simms, Tom Cannon and Ishe Samuels-Smith, which has boosted the club’s PSR position.
With no fewer than 11 of the current first-team squad due to be out of contract next summer or coming to the end of their loan spell, there is now scope for a major rebuilding project when Everton move into their new 52,888 capacity stadium by the banks of the Mersey, which will allow them to play in front of the biggest regular crowds in the club’s history.
Under the Friedkin Group, Roma had a net outlay of over £100m in 2021/22, which was comfortably a club record, while they also splashed out around £75m this summer, with a net spend of some £54m.