CLEVELAND, Ohio — The quest to become an NFL starting quarterback extends far beyond spiral, accuracy and field vision. As the Orange and Brown Talk podcast’s latest episode reveals, a player’s off-field conduct can significantly influence their standing in a competitive position battle — a reality now facing Browns rookie Shedeur Sanders after multiple speeding incidents.
The podcast hosts delivered a masterclass in understanding the comprehensive nature of NFL quarterback evaluation. Mary Kay Cabot, veteran Browns reporter, explained how Sanders’ recent 101 mph speeding ticket and missed court appearance have become part of his professional assessment.
“Right now, everything that these guys are doing, especially the rookies, they’re definitely being scrutinized, but everything that these guys are doing in the quarterback competition, it’s all being thrown into the hopper,” Cabot stated emphatically. “And what you do off the field and what you do on the field, it all matters. It’s all part of the evaluation.”
This incident doesn’t occur in isolation but amid a four-way quarterback competition where Sanders is trying to prove he’s ready for the NFL spotlight. Host Dan Labbe articulated the central question now hanging over Sanders: “Are you ready to be the starting quarterback for the Cleveland Browns and be the guy that’s ready to be the face of this team? And are you going to make good decisions? Are we going to have to deal with stories like this over and over again?”
What makes quarterback evaluation particularly intense is the position’s unique visibility and leadership responsibilities. As Browns beat reporter Ashley Bastock noted on the podcast, “There’s so much pressure that comes with that job. It’s unlike, really, I would say, like any other position in sports, not just in the NFL, but in sports. It is unlike anything else in terms of how much is on you.”
The podcast conversation highlighted how Sanders’ incidents have likely triggered a response from the Browns organization that extends beyond public statements. Cabot suggested the speeding represents a “red flag” requiring immediate attention: “And I think it says, OK, let’s literally pump the brakes a little bit here and figure out what’s going on and make sure that he’s OK in his mentals and everything.”
For Sanders, these incidents could affect his trajectory in both subtle and significant ways. While the hosts acknowledged this doesn’t permanently disqualify him from becoming Cleveland’s starter, it adds an unwanted variable to his evaluation. As Labbe noted, Sanders has likely already been summoned to head coach Kevin Stefanski’s office — not the kind of meeting any player wants during a quarterback competition.
The conversation also touched on the immense pressure facing young quarterbacks adjusting to NFL life. From being away from family for perhaps the first time to handling newfound wealth and responsibility, the challenges extend beyond the playbook. The podcast raises important questions about how teams identify and develop not just physical talent but emotional maturity and judgment.
For Browns fans following the quarterback battle, the Orange and Brown Talk podcast offers valuable insight into the multidimensional evaluation process happening behind the scenes. Listen to the full episode to hear the hosts’ complete breakdown of how Sanders’ off-field conduct might influence his chances of becoming Cleveland’s next franchise quarterback.
Here’s the podcast for this week:
Listen and subscribe to the Orange and Brown Talk podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com's Browns reporters.
Note: Artificial intelligence was used to help generate this story from the Cleveland Orange and Brown Talk Podcast by cleveland.com. Visitors to cleveland.com have asked for more text stories based on website podcast discussions.