The Argentine is facing turbulent times at Old Trafford this summer
Alejandro Garnacho, just 20 years old, is attracting attention in the media for all sorts of reasons in the summer transfer window. The Argentine was one of the hottest prospects in the football world, but he did not have the best season in the Red jersey in the 2024/25 season. However, instead of establishing himself, the young winger seems increasingly distant from the project. As Manchester United results fluctuated throughout the year, Garnacho’s role became more uncertain. Instead of establishing himself, the young winger now seems increasingly distant from the project. What once seemed like a rising star is now failing due to technical decisions and signs of discontent. With clubs such as Aston Villa and Chelsea on the prowl, and a player visibly upset with his situation, the stage is being set for a possible departure from Old Trafford.
Aston Villa Supported in Chase for Man United Star as Club’s Position Becomes Clear
At Manchester United, Garnacho is no longer a certainty for their new project. The Europa League final against Tottenham practically sealed his fate. Ruben Amorim did not put him in the first team, and also sidelined him from the squad in the final match day against Aston Villa. His absence attracted a lot of media attention. The press was quick to link his anger to a possible departure. Meanwhile, Football Insider revealed that Chelsea could be back in the running, and now Villa is joining the fray, pushed by comments from Gabby Agbonlahor, who openly called on the club to sign the Argentine. Unai Emery is watching closely.
“I like him, I think he’s a very good player,” Agbonlahor said.
“Yes, he’s spat his dummy out at times and I don’t blame him. If he’s played well then been left out in a poor Manchester United side, fan favourite as well…
“He’s just got to learn, he’s still a kid, 20 years of age, I think he’s got all the attributes.
“Can he work on his crossing? Can he work on his last pass? Sometimes he’ll shoot when you can cross, he’ll cross when he can shoot.
“But that’s a young player, that’s what they do. I’ll have him, get him down now!”
Opinion:
If United want to avoid another sporting debacle, they must make big decisions with Garnacho. The boy has room for improvement, but he also has reasons to feel relegated. Letting the Argentine go to a direct rival like Aston Villa would be an unnecessary blow. It’s not just about talent, but it’s about identity.
Garnacho represents the kind of player with personality, with unpredictability, with a positive rebelliousness that is lacking in English football. His style connects with the fans, and his departure would not be just another transfer: it would be a symbolic loss. If Garnacho ends up at a team with a manager like Emery, the punishment could come quickly and mercilessly.
Alejandro Garnacho: Manchester United’s Rising Star at a Crossroads
The most logical thing would be to sit down with Garnacho, without beating around the bush or making excuses, and rethink the project. United need to be clear: what role will he play, what is expected of him, what commitment does he want to show? It’s not every day you have a young winger who has already proven himself in big games. Not renewing Garnacho’s contract and letting his anger grow will only lower his price and make his departure inevitable.
More Manchester United News:
If Aston Villa manage to close that deal, the blow to United fans’ morale will be immediate. Seeing one of their own dressed in claret and blue, scoring goals, assisting and celebrating with Unai Emery, will hurt more than defeat in any derby. It’s not just losing talent, but also losing a face of the future. A boy who, despite everything, could still be an idol if he were looked after properly.
United should act now with a clear urgency. They need to secure his future with a new contract, a clear role, and the promise that he won’t be just another player. Garnacho isn’t untouchable, but he’s not expendable either, and if he leaves, the club will be solely responsible. However, if both parties don’t arrive at a possible solution, then it will be best for the club and the Argentine to split their future ways.