Moise Kean has been on Manchester United’s radar for several months, and speculation about his potential departure from Fiorentina is intensifying. The Italian striker enjoyed a standout season, netting 25 goals in 44 appearances and catching the eye of several top European clubs.
However, before diving into United’s interest, it’s important to understand the current landscape at Old Trafford. Once a powerhouse in European football, Manchester United are now navigating a period of stagnation, marked by inconsistent transfer strategies, internal dressing room tensions, and performances that fall short of the club’s illustrious legacy.
According to Fiorentina News, former Viola goalkeeper Emiliano Viviano has voiced skepticism about Kean’s possible move to England. While he acknowledges the stature of Manchester United, he questions whether such an environment would be the right fit for the young forward at this stage in his career.
Moise Kean has been on the radar of the Red Devils and has now been warned against moving a move
“I hope the boy understands that Florence can still give him a lot: on more coveted stages he has in fact shown that he has failed, and Fiorentina could be ideal for him for at least another year,” he said.
“Manchester’s interest? It is true that, on a sporting level, Manchester United are not shining, but they are still one of the most important clubs in the history of football, with considerable economic power.
“Lately, anyone who has gone there has done badly and I think it will be difficult for him to do worse than already done by his predecessors.”
When assessing Manchester United’s present and future under Rúben Amorim, the key question isn’t whether Moise Kean can score goals, it’s whether he can do so consistently in a league as demanding as the Premier League.
His talent is unquestionable, but his stints at top clubs like Juventus and PSG have yielded mixed results. At 25, Kean still has room to grow, yet there remain doubts over whether he possesses the mentality and leadership required to spearhead a rebuilding attack. Amorim prioritises discipline, intensity, and tactical intelligence, qualities Kean has not always demonstrated, particularly in high-pressure moments where his lapses in focus and discipline have been evident.
Can he overcome that pattern and thrive where others have stumbled? It’s not impossible, but it will demand a major shift in mentality. In Florence, he’s comfortable, surrounded by support, playing with rhythm, and thriving in a system that suits him. Leaving that behind for the volatility of Old Trafford carries more risk than reward unless he’s truly ready for the challenge.
More Manchester United News:
Leaving now, just when Moise Kean has finally found consistency and confidence could be premature. At Fiorentina, he enjoys regular minutes, trust from the coaching staff, and the space to continue growing. At Manchester United, he would risk becoming just another short-term experiment in a long list of attacking gambles.
If Kean truly aspires to return to a top-tier club, he must do so as a complete forward, not as a work in progress. Likewise, if United are serious about ending their cycle of failed striker signings, they must start looking beyond raw goal numbers. Kean may not fare worse than some of his predecessors, but he has yet to show that he can shoulder the pressure and expectations that come with leading the line at Old Trafford.
Meanwhile, United appear to be closing in on Brentford’s Bryan Mbeumo as part of their ongoing summer rebuild.