In a football world that is increasingly focused on tactics, intelligence (or rather, the way in which a player perceives and understands the pitch and its space) has become one of the most sought-after qualities. But intelligent players have always shown themselves on the pitch.
And many of them have gone on to play for Manchester United. After all, there is a reason why the legendary English club has become so famous. With that in mind, GIVEMESPORT wondered which Red Devils had demonstrated the most during their careers. Grok AI helped us find the answers. Judge for yourself.
15 Gary Neville
England
gary neville man utd
What Grok AI said: “A tactically astute right-back, Neville's game-reading and leadership as captain underpinned eight Premier League titles and two Champions Leagues.”
Of the many great players to have graduated from Carrington, Gary Neville is certainly one of the most iconic. A member of the famous Class of '92, the player who made 602 appearances for Manchester United is still considered one of the greatest right-backs in football history. Fast, powerful and an excellent ball handler, the charismatic leader of the Red Devils, his beloved club, embodies the very best of the English team, with 85 caps for the Three Lions.
14 Juan Mata
Spain
Juan Mata celebrates
What Grok AI said: “A creative midfielder with superb vision, Mata’s intelligent playmaking and clutch performances (e.g., FA Cup 2016) made him a standout despite fewer trophies.”
An elegant player with phenomenal vision, capable of unlocking any situation with a stroke of genius, Juan Mata's United career perhaps never lived up to its potential. This was due in no small part to the fact that the club was in the midst of a complete rebuild and suffering from chronic instability following the departure of Sir Alex Ferguson. But that did not stop the Spaniard from displaying all his qualities and helping the club win four titles, including the Europa League in 2017.
13 Cristiano Ronaldo
Portugal
What Grok AI said: “In his first United stint, Ronaldo’s intelligence in movement and decision-making elevated him to a 2008 Ballon d’Or, with three Premier Leagues and a Champions League.”
To talk about Cristiano Ronaldo is to talk about one of the greatest players in the history of football. Some would even say the best. It's a reputation that the Portuguese star has forged over the years with memorable performances at some of the world's biggest clubs.
Starting with Manchester United, where he exploded before offering himself a transfer to Real Madrid. So when it was announced in 2021 that the prodigal son would be returning to Old Trafford, it was as a hero that the five-time Ballon d'Or winner was welcomed back home. And he did them proud.
12 Duncan Edwards
England
MixCollage-20-Mar-2025-09-59-PM-624
What Grok AI said: “A prodigy cut short, Edwards’ versatility and footballing brain shone in midfield and defence, contributing to three league titles before his tragic death at 21.”
Duncan Edwards began his career at Manchester United at the age of 16. And to say he made an immediate impact would be an understatement. A player of immense talent, recognised by some of his peers as the best player they had ever played with, he unfortunately saw his career take a tragic turn in 1958, when he was one of the many victims of the Munich Air Disaster. He was just 21 years old.
11 Nemanja Vidic
Serbia
Nemanja Vidic
What Grok AI said: “A commanding centre-back, Vidic’s tactical discipline and ability to organise the defence were crucial for five Premier League titles and the 2008 Champions League.”
Considered as one of the hardest players in the history of the Premier League, Nemanja Vidic's reputation has preceded him. Imposing, hard on the man and powerful, the Serb is an emblematic figure of the great Manchester United of the 2000s, with whom he won five English league titles and one Champions League. The impressive images of his duels and bloodied face have been shown around the world, perfectly illustrating his warrior nature.
10 Denis Law
Scotland
MixCollage-17-Jan-2025-07-56-PM-7766
What Grok AI said: “A clinical striker with a knack for positioning, Law’s intelligent movement led to 237 goals, a European Cup, and two league titles, earning him the 1964 Ballon d’Or.”
There have been many kings who have ruled England over the ages. Denis Law is one of them — and not the least important. Scorer of 237 goals in 404 appearances for Manchester United (which he represented for 13 years), the Scotsman was notably renowned for the lethality of his shots. One of the numerous qualities that helped him win the Ballon d'Or in 1964 and forge a reputation worthy of the greatest.
9 Michael Carrick
England
Michael Carrick
What Grok AI said: “A deep-lying playmaker with exceptional composure, Carrick’s subtle game-reading and passing anchored United to five Premier League titles and a Champions League.”
When it comes to remembering the most underrated players in football history, it is very likely that the name of Michael Carrick is among those most quickly mentioned. Because maybe he was not the flashiest of footballers, but the midfielder was nonetheless one of the most effective. And that's something everyone who played alongside him knows. In fact, the multiple titles he won with the Red Devils are just the reward for an exemplary career.
8 Bryan Robson
England
What Grok AI said: “Known as 'Captain Marvel,' Robson’s all-action midfield play combined tactical nous with leadership, securing three league titles and a Cup Winners’ Cup.”
If ever there was a player who epitomised the concept of resilience, it is none other than Bryan Robson. After suffering no fewer than three broken legs early in his career, while still playing for West Bromwich Albion, the Englishman bounced back perfectly to establish himself as one of the greatest British players of all time. His time at Old Trafford, which notably included two English league titles and a Cup Winners' Cup, is clear proof of this.
7 Wayne Rooney
England
Wayne Rooney
What Grok AI said: “United’s all-time top scorer (253 goals), Rooney’s versatility (striker to midfielder) and game awareness were vital for five Premier League titles and a Champions League.”
Ronaldo Nazario (Brazil) in the middle with, Zlatan Ibrahimovic (PSG), and Karim Benzema (Real Madrid) Related
10 Greatest Strikers of the 21st Century [Ranked]
These 10 great 21st-century strikers, including Thierry Henry, knew how to find the back of the net.
There are few strikers who can claim to have reached the same heights as Wayne Rooney. An iconic figure at Manchester United, the England striker is the club's all-time top scorer with 253 goals in 559 games. A player with a versatile profile, capable of setting up his target from any position as well as travelling 80 metres to retrieve the ball from his opponent's feet, Rooney remains in the pantheon of the greatest players in the history of the Red Devils.
6 George Best
Northern Ireland
George Best at Manchester United
What Grok AI said: “A dazzling talent with an instinctive understanding of space and timing, Best’s intelligence in exploiting defences earned him a European Cup and two league titles.”
As talented as he was controversial, George Best wrote his legend during a brilliant career with Manchester United. One of the greatest right-wingers in the history of the game, the Northern Irishman was gifted with an impressive and varied range of skills, combining speed, agility and ingenuity. In the eyes of Red Devils fans, he will forever be remembered as the man who helped them win the European Cup in 1968, sealing his election as Ballon d'Or winner in the process.
"Manchester United’s glorious history has been created by people like George Best. Anyone that witnessed what George Best could do on the pitch wished they could do the same."
Sir Bobby Charlton about George Best