We all want the very best for our team: top-quality players, big wins, and unforgettable moments. But let’s be honest, there’s often a twinge of envy when we see our rivals line up with world-class talent, especially when it feels like our own squad is just a few key signings away from truly competing.
So, if you had the chance to sign one player from another club, who would it be?
While seeing stars like Declan Rice, Erling Haaland, or Bruno Fernandes in Royal Blue at Hill Dickinson Stadium may be a stretch, we've tried to keep these picks as realistic as possible, grounded in what could actually happen. Let’s get started.
Arsenal - MF Fabio Vieira
The Portuguese midfielder finds himself an unwanted man at Arsenal following an underwhelming loan spell at Porto, where he failed to convince the club to pursue a permanent deal. Meanwhile, Everton are in desperate need of a creative midfielder, someone who can dictate play, pick a pass, and connect midfield to attack.
At a reported fee of £15–20 million, he represents a relatively low-cost option for a player with international pedigree and untapped potential.
Aston Villa - MF John McGinn
David Moyes is reportedly continuing his efforts to persuade Aston Villa captain John McGinn to make the switch to Everton, with rumours of the move remaining persistent since first emerging in a shock transfer deal.
The combative midfielder would bring passion, leadership, and high-intensity pressing, all qualities that align perfectly with the style Moyes is expected to implement at Goodison Park.
Bournemouth - MF Ryan Christie
Andoni Iraola’s squad has taken a hit defensively this summer, with Ilya Zabarnyi reportedly close to joining European champions Paris Saint-Germain. While Mark Travers appears set for a move to Everton, that alone isn’t enough to whet my excitement, so to speak.
The real game-changer could be Ryan Christie, a creative spark capable of transforming Everton into genuine European contenders as he sits alongside the defensive midfielder.
Brentford - LB Aaron Hickey
A left-back with the potential to develop into a regular first-team player, he offers plenty going forward while remaining reliable defensively when dealing with wide threats. Comfortable on both flanks, he also provides valuable versatility, similar to what Ashley Young offered.
However, injuries have become a growing concern, with only nine appearances across the last two seasons. Perhaps a fresh start can not only revive his career but also restore his fitness and confidence at a crucial stage.
Brighton - MF Matt O’Riley
A technically gifted midfielder with an eye for a pass, Matt O’Riley would add composure and creativity to Everton’s engine room.
After impressing at Celtic, the move to Brighton has seemingly slowed his Premier League readiness, but if faith is shown, they could land a player capable of dictating tempo, contributing goals, and linking midfield to attack in a way the current squad lacks. Linked with Roma, maybe the Friedkin Group would give their priority to Everton to seal the transfer.
Burnley - CB Maxime Estève
His standout Championship season saw him contribute to an incredible 30 clean sheets and only 16 goals conceded in 46 games, earning him a spot in the Team of the Season.
The eventual replacement for James Tarkowski post this season, will form a formidable partnership with Jarrad Branthwaite for many years to come. A physically imposing centre-back (6ft 4in) with a strong aerial presence and good passing range, evidenced by his high pass accuracy.
You might notice a strong Scottish influence in the selections, with a few names from outside Europe making the cut as well. You may agree or disagree with the picks, and that’s part of the fun. Let us know who you would choose from the clubs listed above. Just keep it realistic, no Saka or Semenyo signings here!