Manchester United went into the Manchester Derby hoping to make a statement, but instead fell to a painful 3-0 defeat at the Etihad.
There were brief glimpses of attacking promise, but United once again lacked the quality, ruthlessness, and defensive resilience needed to compete with Pep Guardiola’s side.
Here are four key takeaways from the match, viewed through the United lens.
Amad’s Attacking Role Deserves More Attention
Embed from Getty Images
One of the few bright sparks was Amad’s positioning in attack. Deployed higher up the pitch, he showed a willingness to take on defenders, drift into central areas, and link play in transitions. His movement often unsettled City’s back line and gave United an outlet that others failed to provide.
However, his influence was limited because United struggled to sustain possession and create consistent service for him.
If United are serious about building for the future, they need to give Amad more opportunities in attacking roles — his technical ability and composure could be vital in unlocking tight defenses.
United Get Into Dangerous Areas But Waste Them
Embed from Getty Images
For all of City’s dominance, United still carved out situations where they were in dangerous attacking positions.
Whether it was on the break or when City briefly left gaps at the back, United found themselves in promising areas. The problem? They consistently failed to capitalize on these positions. Poor decision-making, heavy touches, and a lack of precision in the final third meant that potential chances fizzled out.
Against lesser teams, these moments might go unpunished. Against City, every wasted opportunity is magnified — and this time, it directly contributed to the heavy scoreline.
Ruthlessness Remains the Missing Ingredient
Embed from Getty Images
The gulf in class was clearest in front of goal. Manchester City were ruthless, making the most of their chances, while United were anything but. This isn’t just about missing shots — it’s about mentality.
City turned half-chances into goals by being sharp, decisive, and relentless. United, on the other hand, hesitated in key moments, playing one pass too many or failing to execute with conviction.
This lack of ruthlessness has haunted United throughout the season, and unless they find a killer edge, they will continue to come up short in the biggest games.
Defensive Fragility Undermines the Attack
Embed from Getty Images
Even when United looked like they could build some momentum, their defensive structure let them down. The back line struggled to cope with City’s movement, failing to track runners and leaving gaps in transition. Once City broke through, the result was almost inevitable.
United cannot hope to beat elite opposition when defensive lapses undo any attacking progress. The defeat wasn’t just about missed chances up front — it was about the inability to keep things tight and disciplined at the back.
Final Thought
This match was a reminder of where United stand right now: flashes of attacking potential, but far too many weaknesses in both boxes.
Amad showed promise, and the team did find themselves in attacking positions, but without composure, ruthlessness, and defensive resilience, those moments mean little. To close the gap on City — and the other elite sides — United must turn dangerous positions into goals and fragile defending into solid foundations.