It was shaping up to be a statement win—the one that finally flipped the script. Russell Wilson turned back the clock, Malik Nabers went berserk, and the New York Giants were literal seconds away from stealing a wild shootout in Arlington. But just when it looked like Big Blue was finally going to close the deal, the defense stepped in and said, "Not on my watch."
The G-Men took a 37–34 lead with 25 seconds left, while the Cowboys had no timeouts. The moment called for one final stop. Instead, defensive coordinator Shane Bowen gave Dak Prescott a 20-yard buffer, played prevent defense, and left the middle of the field wide open... twice. Apparently, 25 seconds was too much time for the defense. Cowboys kicker Brandon Aubrey drilled a 64-yard field goal to send the game to overtime. Then he hit the 46-yarder to win it.
The Giants are now winless through two games, and Sunday’s unraveling in Dallas had everything to do with a defense that gave up 478 yards and couldn’t hold up when they needed it most. It was an all-around meltdown, and CBS Sports’ Dan Schneier captured the mood of the fanbase with one savage, yet accurate line:
"The Giants have the worst DC in all of football."
Dan Schneier about Shane Bowen
Giants’ defensive collapse vs Cowboys puts spotlight on Shane Bowen
This one isn’t hard to diagnose. It’s not about personnel. It’s clearly about scheme. Bowen is taking a defense loaded with frontline talent — Dexter Lawrence, Kayvon Thibodeaux, Brian Burns, Abdul Carter — and somehow making them irrelevant when it matters most. The results are brutal.
The Giants currently rank dead last in total defense. They’re giving up over 450 yards a game and nearly 31 points per outing. And all roads point back to the guy calling the shots.
Let’s talk about that second-and-long call from Sunday. With 19 seconds left in regulation, Dallas had the ball at their own 33. Big Blue had already shown that pressure disrupted Dak’s timing a bit. They’d hit him seven times and sacked him thrice. So what did the DC do? He dropped everyone... sat the defense deep, and let the Cowboys grab an easy 18 yards to set up the game-tying kick.
It was prevent defense at its most cowardly. And when Schneier says it out loud, he’s not alone. Giants fans are furious, and rightfully so. They’ve watched this team trip over itself under his leadership for 19 games too many, all while the defense does the same thing, expecting a different result.
The worst part is that this was no fluke. This is becoming his thing. It'd be nice if coaching defense was his thing, but what can you do?
With Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs looming in Week 3, Brian Daboll might have to make the call no one wants to make but everyone sees coming. If Shane Bowen has another meltdown on primetime TV, the only thing he’ll be coordinating is his move out of the building. He's running out of chances to prove Schneier (and everyone else) wrong.
More New York Giants news and analysis