In the middle of an NFC playoff push, the Detroit Lions are buzzing with anticipation over a potential comeback. J.J. McCarthy, the team’s 2024 first-round pick, could soon return to practice after being sidelined for weeks with a shoulder injury. His return would not only reshape the quarterback room but could also alter the team’s late-season strategy, creating a compelling storyline in Detroit.
Sep 14, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy (9) reacts after the game against the Atlanta Falcons at U.S. Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Matt Krohn-Imagn Images
The defining questions for the Lions are not just when J.J. McCarthy will return, but also how well-prepared he will be when he does. Head coach Dan Campbell has been cautious about rushing the 21-year-old quarterback, prioritizing his long-term development over any short-term gains. This approach has led to a steady but measured progression for McCarthy.
Over the last two weeks, his throwing workload has gradually increased, which shows that the Detroit medical staff is focused on ensuring his durability. This careful planning is a key factor in his recovery timeline.
> Campbell has hinted that McCarthy’s next step will depend on “how comfortable he feels taking full-speed reps.” The Lions coach praised his mental growth, saying the rookie has “handled the playbook and sideline adjustments like a pro.”
>
> “We’re not going to force anything,” [Campbell](https://southfloridatribune.com/lions-offensive-coordinator-john-morton-lions-defensive-coordinator-kelvin-sheppard-and-lions-special-teams-coordinator-dave-fipp-quote-sheet-8/?utm_source=) said during Thursday’s presser. “J.J.’s doing everything right. When he’s fully ready, we’ll know and he’ll know.”
Meanwhile, Detroit’s current starter, Jared Goff, has kept the offense performing consistently. Through Week 8, he ranks among the NFC’s top five quarterbacks in completion percentage at 69.4% and has maintained a 102.7 passer rating. Despite Goff’s solid play, McCarthy’s development remains crucial for the franchise’s long-term outlook.
If McCarthy returns in Week 10, as projected by _NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport (reported November 1, 2025)_, the team is expected to integrate him slowly. This plan would likely involve limited packages and situational drives, with an emphasis on protecting his shoulder. The Detroit staff views this as a “build-up phase,” not a quarterback controversy.
For now, the Lions are playing the long game. McCarthy’s readiness will be judged not just by his health, but by how effectively he can command an NFL huddle, something the Lions believe is only a matter of time.