Arne Slot is not the first Liverpool boss to find rebuilding a team and defending a trophy easy, but the manager he faced on Sunday shows there is a way
Liverpool head coach Arne Slot shakes hands with Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola during the Premier League match at Etihad Stadium on November 9 2025View 2 Images
As the dominant force in the modern Premier League era, Manchester City have for much of the past decade been the benchmark for Liverpool. Now the Reds must once again look down the other end of the M62 for inspiration.
Dismal defeat at the Etihad on Sunday afternoon for the reigning Premier League champions confirmed suspicions Pep Guardiola's side are once again the team most likely to prevent Arsenal ending what would be a 22-year wait to win the title this season.
Indeed, talk of a championship challenge was far from the mind of Arne Slot as he grapples with a run of form that has seen Liverpool now lose five of their last six Premier League games and seven of their last 10 matches in all competitions.
Even when acknowledging all the long-established understandable caveats, Slot readily admits there can be no excusing the Reds slumping to eighth in the table, their lowest position since April 2023.
Despite 26 points from their last 10 games that season, Liverpool missed out on Champions League qualification. And while such fears this term are premature - only 11 games have played and the Reds stand just one point off the top four - there's little doubt targets and expectations are now having to be realigned.
Defending a major trophy has proven beyond Liverpool for the past 41 years, a remarkable fact given they are English football's most decorated club. The last time came in 1984 when they won a third league title in a row.
Since then, Manchester United have retained the championship six times, City four times and Chelsea once. Arsenal (twice) and Chelsea (once) have gone back-to-back in the FA Cup while City have done so three times in the League Cup with Nottingham Forest and Manchester United managing it on a single occasion each.
This season, of course, has been a somewhat unusual case, with Slot compelled to overhaul parts of his team in a manner normally befitting a team wanting to make the next step up rather than fortify from a position of strength.
While some comparisons can be made to the extensive business his predecessor Jurgen Klopp undertook after this first season - Sadio Mane, Joel Matip and Gini Wijnaldum would become mainstays during a period of success - Klopp hadn't had the luxury of an initial window having joined partway through the 2015/16 campaign.
Gini Wijnaldum, who turns 35 today, with Jurgen Klopp at the Liverpool team hotel on July 23, 2016 in Palo Alto, California after signing from Newcastle UnitedView 2 Images
Rebuilding a team isn't easy and rarely goes as initially intended. Even Liverpool legends such as Bill Shankly and Bob Paisley found it difficult, the former going seven years without a trophy after the success of his first team while Paisley took the best part of 18 months to find the right combination before his final great side clicked into gear and went on to win the first of those three successive titles in 1982.
Indeed, having completed that hat-trick, going into their 12th game of the 1984/85 season Liverpool found themselves 20th in a 22-team top division. They ended that season second and won the league and FA Cup double the following year.
The landscape may have vastly changed in the subsequent 40 years but the underlying challenge has not. Which brings us back to the present day and Guardiola's City.
This time last season, having won 10 and drawn four of their opening 14 games, City had suffered a fourth successive loss and were in the midst of a run of nine defeats in 12 games in all competitions, six in the Premier League.
The realisation they needed to refresh their squad had come too late, and prompted a January transfer splurge - not all of which has worked out - and a further spend in the summer.
Find more about Liverpool handed new referee verdict on Virgil van Dijk goal as Premier League told mistake made
Find more about Jurgen Klopp's text messages to Arne Slot and opinion of struggling Liverpool boss
Find more about Gary Neville tells Liverpool to 'call it as it is' over summer signing after dismal display
Find more about I spoke to Virgil van Dijk after Erling Haaland masterclass - he was so angry he walked away
Find more about Liverpool handed new referee verdict after controversial Virgil van Dijk decision is unpicked
Find more about National media react to 'wretched' Liverpool defeat at Man City - 'Why is anybody surprised'
Find more about Vitalii Mykolenko makes honest admission about how he needs to improve at Everton - 'Truth is'
While a number of results this season would suggest City still remain a work in progress, few would doubt they look more formidable than 12 months previous and appear a lot nearer the finished article than Liverpool at present. It took time, and a few missteps, for Guardiola to get closer to his wanted mix.
And it seems Liverpool are travelling that path now. City have shown they can come out of an unexpected and uncharacteristic dreadful patch with genuine hope of future success. The challenge for Slot now is to ensure Liverpool do likewise.