CLEVELAND, Ohio — The Cavs may have beaten the Memphis Grizzlies 108-100, but the victory didn’t mask a deeper, more complicated truth about the team’s long-term trajectory.
On the latest episode of the Wine and Gold Talk podcast, cleveland.com beat reporter Chris Fedor delivered a blunt assessment that reframed the conversation around the franchise’s most important player: Evan Mobley.
“So many people inside the organization tend to say that Jarrett Allen is the barometer for this team’s success. And I don’t think that’s true,” Fedor said. “I think it’s Evan Mobley. I think how Evan Mobley plays dictates the Cavs’ ceiling and whether they’re winning these games in the short term.
“The Cavs took the leap last year because Evan Mobley took the leap.”
For three quarters, the 24-year-old appeared tentative, drifting through offensive possessions and failing to assert himself defensively the way he did during last season’s Second Team All-NBA campaign. And then, as if a switch flipped, Mobley dominated the fourth quarter.
Podcast host Ethan Sands captured the shift succinctly: “Evan Mobley was simply more aggressive. He had eight points, was a plus-16, had seven rebounds and two assists [in the final frame]. This is a guy that was playing timid for the first three quarters, and I don’t know what happened in the fourth period, but he simply had a different aggressiveness to him from the start.”
That fourth-quarter version of Mobley — the assertive, dynamic two-way force who helped combine with Donovan Mitchell for 22 of the Cavs’ 32 points in the final frame — is the player Cleveland needs on a nightly basis. Not occasionally. Not situationally. Nightly.
Fedor didn’t mince words on that point:
“Greatness and stardom is not a sometimes thing. And until he plays at a more consistent level, I think you’re going to see an offense that is stuck in the mud.”
The critique stings because the Cavs know exactly what Mobley is capable of.
Last season’s leap saw Mobley anchor one of the league’s best defenses, expanded his offensive toolkit, and became the difference maker of a 64-win team that bulldozed its way to the top of the Eastern Conference standings. He looked like a future franchise pillar, the kind of two-way big whose presence determines a team’s ceiling.
This season, that version of Mobley has surfaced only in bursts. The inconsistency has left Cleveland searching for offensive rhythm and a larger identity.
As Sands put it on the podcast, the team is in something of an “identity crisis,” and Mobley’s fluctuating assertiveness sits at the center of that conflict.
But the podcast also pointed to a potential solution — one hiding in plain sight.
Much like last season, Mobley’s best quarter of the year came while sharing the floor with Donovan Mitchell. Fedor underscored the significance of that pairing.
“I don’t think it’s coincidental that the best quarter that Evan has played maybe all season long, it coincided with being on the floor the entire time next to Donovan Mitchell,” he said. “They built something last year.”
With Darius Garland’s return looming, head coach Kenny Atkinson will soon face rotation decisions that could influence the team’s trajectory.
Does Cleveland need to intentionally recreate the Mitchell-Mobley synergy that powered last season’s late-season surge? Should those minutes become a priority rather than a byproduct of substitution patterns?
The fourth quarter against Memphis offered a compelling case study. Mobley didn’t just produce—he played with a clarity and confidence that elevated everyone around him. That’s the version of Evan Mobley the Cavaliers believe can drive them deep into the postseason. That’s the version that makes a championship run feel plausible.
The question now is how often they can access it.
For a deeper dive into the Cavs’ evolving identity and Mobley’s role in shaping the franchise’s ceiling, listen to the full episode of the Wine and Gold Talk podcast, featuring analysis from Chris Fedor and Ethan Sands.
Here’s the podcast for this week:
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.