CLEVELAND, Ohio — Shedeur Sanders’ first NFL start for the Browns isn’t just about one game or even about the rookie’s future — it’s potentially a referendum on the entire front office’s ability to evaluate the quarterback position. If the fifth-round pick shows promise where more highly-touted options have failed, it could raise uncomfortable questions about the team’s quarterback strategy under the current regime.
Browns beat reporter Ashley Bastock framed the stakes clearly: " I think (if he plays well), it’s going to make some really interesting conversations about this team, this regime, this coaching staff and their ability to evaluate quarterbacks. And there’s going to be a lot of re-litigating of that four man quarterback competition and Shedeur Sanders place in it."
The Browns’ quarterback carousel has spun at a dizzying rate. After moving on from Deshaun Watson due to injury, the team has cycled through options at a pace that suggests fundamental evaluation flaws. “Look, we’ve been talking about this idea of they bring in two vets and they’re both traded by Week 5. It just seems like nothing has gone according to their own plan,” Bastock noted, highlighting the unstable quarterback situation.
She continued with a biting observation about a concerning pattern: “And now I’m wondering, for a couple straight years now, have we seen them overestimate young quarterbacks in the preseason and just hand over the reins too soon?”
What makes Sanders’ opportunity particularly fascinating is that the Browns themselves passed on him multiple times during the draft before eventually selecting him in the fifth round. Orange and Brown Talk host Dan Labbe pointed out this irony: “It’s a leap to say Shedeur Sanders can be that guy because again, fifth-round pick, a lot of teams passed on him, the Browns passed on him a bunch. What you’re rolling the dice on here is you’re hoping to land a Brock Purdy-like, miracle, where you find a guy on Day 3 of the draft and he ends up being your guy.”
The comparison to Purdy — a seventh-round success story for the 49ers — highlights both the longshot nature of Sanders’ potential success and the extraordinary embarrassment it would cause the front office if their fifth-round afterthought outperforms their carefully selected veteran options and QB they picked two rounds earlier.
For a franchise that has spent enormous capital trying to solve its quarterback problem — from the failed Deshaun Watson trade to cycling through multiple veterans — having a Day 3 draft pick emerge as the best option would represent a damning indictment of their evaluation process.
The Sanders experiment also raises questions about the Browns’ player development approach. If he shows meaningful progress despite limited practice reps earlier in the season, it would suggest the team may have mishandled his development by not giving him more opportunities sooner.
As the Browns head to Las Vegas, Sanders’ performance will be scrutinized not just for what it means for the team’s immediate future, but for what it reveals about the decision-makers who have repeatedly failed to find stability at the sport’s most important position.
Here’s the latest podcast:
Listen and subscribe to the Orange and Brown Talk podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com's Browns reporters.
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.