LAS VEGAS — The Cleveland Browns' season may be spiraling at 3-8, but for one Sunday in Las Vegas, rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders provided something that’s been missing all year: explosive plays and a glimmer of hope.
Making his first NFL start against the Raiders, the fifth-round pick delivered a performance that was equal parts electrifying and erratic. The final numbers -- 11-of-20 for 209 yards with one touchdown and one interception -- don’t tell the full story of a debut that has ignited fierce debate among Browns fans and analysts.
The most telling statistic? In just one game, Sanders produced the Browns’ three longest offensive plays of the entire season.
" I really do believe that you need to seize the momentum here," Browns beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot said on the latest Orange and Brown Talk podcast. “And he brought some new energy, some new life to the offense. Again, it was against the 2-9 Raiders. We do understand that. But he was able to push the ball downfield, and I think that that was the best thing that he did.”
That downfield ability was on full display with a perfectly placed 52-yard bomb to Isaiah Bond that had the entire Browns sideline -- including defensive star Myles Garrett -- erupting in celebration. It was the kind of throw that justified the pre-draft hype around Sanders before his surprising slide to the fifth round.
“I think the bottom line is Shedeur has earned that second look and that chance to build,” Browns reporter Ashley Bastock noted. “The reality is the Browns haven’t had any of those plays. He made one start and now suddenly has the three longest offensive plays of the season.”
The rookie’s performance wasn’t without flaws. There were missed throws, an ugly interception and several three-and-outs. But compared to what the Browns have endured offensively this season, Sanders’ willingness to push the ball downfield represented a refreshing change of pace.
“The offense wasn’t fixed today,” podcast host Dan Labbe cautioned. “Shedeur Sanders didn’t become a franchise quarterback today. And the offense at times was still not functional today. But adding that explosive element, we saw what it does.”
The timing creates a genuine quarterback dilemma for head coach Kevin Stefanski. With Dillon Gabriel potentially clearing concussion protocol this week, does the team revert to its original plan or ride the momentum with Sanders?
What makes Sanders particularly intriguing is the natural feel he displayed while making difficult throws. Despite never taking first-team reps until this week of practice, he showed the kind of arm talent and confidence that can’t be taught.
“When you have the kind of elite accuracy and the uncanny touch on the ball that Shedeur has, he feels confident taking those shots,” Cabot explained. “That doesn’t mean that he’s not raw, that he’s not a rookie, and that he doesn’t need a ton of work, because he does.”
The Sanders decision exemplifies the Browns’ current reality: balancing immediate excitement against long-term development. While he may not be the finished product, his ceiling appears higher than what Gabriel has shown.
Want to hear the full breakdown of Sanders’ debut and what it means for the Browns’ quarterback situation? Listen to the entire Orange and Brown Talk podcast where the crew breaks down every aspect of the rookie’s first start and the critical decision ahead for Cleveland.
Here’s the latest podcast:
Listen and subscribe to the Orange and Brown Talk podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com's Browns reporters.
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.