Everton's performance during their 1-0 win over Manchester United fluctuated from the ridiculous to the sublime within the space of just 16 minutes at Old Trafford.
Idrissa Gueye was sent off with just 13 minutes on the clock when he slapped team-mate Michael Keane in a truly bizarre moment which has continued to divide opinion among pundits, fans, referees and even manager David Moyes, who feels the referee could have given his midfielder the benefit of the doubt.
The match appeared destined to drift into United's favour, but the red card only glavanized the Toffees; just over a quarter of an hour later, midfielder Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall cut inside from the left channel and curled a goal into the top right corner, around defender Mattjis De Ligt and away from goalkeeper Senne Lammens.
From there, Everton produced an impeccable defensive performance with just ten men, reducing United to a series of crosses and long-shots to see the game out and grab a massive three points away at Old Trafford. It was the first time Moyes has won there as a visiting manager, despite having arguably his least favourable circumstances of doing so.
Dewsbury-Hall's 29th-minute strike will be remembered as an iconic moment in the game, and his overall performance was impressive, working tirelessly both with and without the ball to register one key pass, one tackle, one interception, six clearances and 30 passes - the joint-most of any outfield player for the Toffees.
But despite the goal, three Everton players had an even bigger impact than him on the night, something backed up by GIVEMESPORT's Player Ratings.
Jordan Pickford - 8.5/10
Jordan Pickford celebrates winning at Old Trafford
It is sometimes easy to overlook just how good Everton have it between the sticks. Jordan Pickford is capable of playing at European level and tonight provided further evidence to endorse that notion. Pickford made six saves to keep his clean sheet, one of which was a truly world-class stop.
It wasn't a great night for Joshua Zirkzee, who struggled at centre-forward for United, but the Dutchman did threaten with a series of headers late in the game. One looked destined to make contact with the woodwork and ricochet into Everton's net, but Pickford got a finger-tip to it to turn Zirkzee's effort around the post.
Pickford was also a mature, calming presence in the immediate aftermath of Gueye's shock sending off. He put his arms around the Senegal international and turned him towards the dressing room to stop any further embarrassment and move on from the situation quickly.
Everton's defensive performance was exceptional but they still required Pickford to spring into action on multiple occasions and he always delivered when needed.
Thierno Barry - 8.5/10
Thierno Barry playing against Manchester United
Playing as a lone striker in a David Moyes team is a pretty tough gig. But when you're down to ten men and away from home, it is nothing short of absolutely grueling.
Thierno Barry has struggled for impact since his summer move from Villarreal; he's yet to score in the Premier League and quite frankly, hasn't looked like he's going to break his duck any time soon either. His xG for this season is 1.68, after eleven appearances.
But there is nothing Moyes will appreciate more up front than a hard worker, and Barry showed against United that he's prepared to put in the tough yards to become a key part of this team. The 23-year-old won an incredible 14 aerial duels, the most any player has won in a single Premier League game this season.
That was a massive factor in Everton's defensive performance. Albeit only for a few seconds here and there, his headers won from largely aimless punts up field gave the Toffees vital respite and occasionally provided a foothold to start attacks.
Barry awaits that all-illusive goal but at least he's showing he can fit Moyes' tactics.
Michael Keane - 9/10
Michael Keane heads a ball
Take a bow, Michael Keane. Being at the centre of such a bizarre incident could have easily rattled him, but it lead to one of his best performances in an Everton shirt.
The centre-back looked calm and composed throughout the game and chalked up two tackles, two interceptions, two blocks, five clearances and three aerials won, all without committing a single foul and producing the best pass completion of any Everton starter (except for the subbed-off Seamus Coleman) at 83%.
Keane was at the beating heart of this crazy game for reasons good and bad, and he'll be especially proud to have produced such a heroic display at Old Trafford, where he failed to break through as a youngster before moving onto Burnley.
Keane's had his critics throughout his time at Everton but he's looked rock solid this season and was impenetrable alongside James Tarkowski on Monday night.