York, 6-1, 206, was originally selected in the fourth round (124th overall) of the 2022 NFL Draft by the Cleveland Browns out of LSU. In 23 games with the Browns (2022), Washington Commanders (2024) and Cincinnati Bengals (2024), the Prosper, Texas native drilled 33-of-45 field goals and 51-of-54 extra points attempts for 150 total points. In 2022, York set Browns rookie records for points (107) and PATs (35), while finishing second for field goals made (24). In 2024, York kicked in one game for Washington and the final five contests of the season for Cincinnati, making nine-of-13 field goal attempts and 16-of-17 PATs.
A three-year letterman at LSU, York was selected second-team All-SEC by conference coaches in 2021 as a junior, connecting on 15-of-18 field goals and all 39 PATs to reach a school-record streak of 118 consecutive PATs made. In 2019, he led the nation in PATs (89) and finished second in the nation in scoring (152 points) as a freshman in 2019 for the National Champions. His 152 points in 2019 were the most by a kicker in college football and second overall.