CLEVELAND, Ohio — The Cavs left Washington D.C. with a win on Friday night, but you wouldn’t know it from the blistering criticism they received on the latest Wine and Gold Talk podcast.
Host Ethan Sands and cleveland.com Cavs beat reporter Chris Fedor discussed Cleveland’s troubling 130-126 victory over the Washington Wizards, a team that has won just three games all season.
“This was not a pretty one. This was an ugly win. And to me, this is still one of the worst games the Cavs have played,” Sands declared in the podcast’s opening minutes, setting the tone for a conversation that focused more on process than outcome.
The victory, which required Donovan Mitchell to score 24 points in the fourth quarter alone — the second-most by any Cavalier in a fourth quarter since the 1997-98 season — exposed fundamental issues that have plagued the team throughout the season.
Fedor was equally blunt in his assessment: “There is no reason to celebrate this thing. There is no reason to point to anything and say, hey, we did this. Well, the only thing that happened is Donovan Mitchell went superhero and delivered one of the best regular season performances of his career.”
What made this performance particularly [alarming was its timing.](https://www.cleveland.com/cavs/2025/12/seen-it-all-how-the-cavs-paused-soundtrack-could-become-their-defining-stretch.html)
The Cavaliers were coming off a five-day break that included what was supposed to be a transformative film session focused on defense. Instead, they allowed the Wizards to score 40 points in the third quarter and 36 in the second.
“You can’t say, hey, we identified this on film and identified this on film and this is going to be better moving forward and then do none of those things against the Washington Wizards,” Fedor emphasized, highlighting the disconnect between the team’s stated intentions and their on-court execution.
The podcast noted that this marked the Cavs’ eighth-worst defensive performance of the season — against a depleted Wizards roster missing key players like Bilal Coulibaly, Khris Middleton and Alex Sarr.
Perhaps most concerning was Fedor’s suggestion that “this makes you feel like this is a team that is tuning out their coach. That’s what it feels like. Whether it is or it isn’t, that’s how it feels. That’s what it looks like.”
For a team that claims to be process-oriented rather than outcome-focused, needing Mitchell to score 35 of the Cavs’ 68 second-half points to beat the league’s worst team represents a significant failure. The hosts compared this game to even the team’s recent loss to Golden State, with Sands arguing this performance might have been worse precisely because it came after time to address their issues.
As Cleveland looks ahead to upcoming games against the Hornets, Bulls, Pelicans and Spurs, the podcast raises important questions about whether this team can make the necessary adjustments to meet their championship aspirations or if they’ll continue to rely on individual heroics to mask their collective shortcomings.
Want to hear the full, fiery breakdown of the Cavs’ concerning win? Listen to the latest Wine and Gold Talk podcast as Ethan and Chris don’t hold back in their assessment of where Cleveland stands 26 games into a season that’s raising more questions than answers.
Here’s the podcast for this week: