CLEVELAND, Ohio — If the Cavs ever do decide to crack open the Core Four, the league already knows where it would start looking.
Darius Garland and Jarrett Allen are the two most tradable pieces. Not because they lack value in Cleveland, but because their skill sets translate everywhere.
A dynamic pick-and-roll guard with shooting gravity. A rim-running, rim-protecting center on a reasonable contract. Around the league, those archetypes are currency.
And yet, Cleveland has continued to resist the temptation.
Part of that reluctance is philosophical. Part of it is contractual, shaped by the second apron. But a meaningful slice comes down to something simpler. The belief is that Garland and Allen, together, still unlock a version of the Cavs that can survive the postseason.
Monday night’s 113-101 win over a surging Spurs team offered a timely reminder of why that belief hasn’t dwindled.
The efficiency of a familiar partnership
Allen finished with 27 points and 10 rebounds, his fifth double-double of the year and arguably his most complete performance. The production mattered, but the context mattered more.
In a season in which the Cavs have already tallied 16 losses — a mark the 2024-25 team didn’t reach until April — they are 7-1 when Allen scores at least 16 points. They are 6-0 when he takes 10 or more shots.
When Allen is not a bystander but a featured participant, Cleveland’s offense tilts toward stability and keeps its big man engaged defensively.
That does not happen by accident. And it almost never happens without Garland.
Garland posted a season-high 11 assists against San Antonio, continuing a stretch that better reflects his current impact than his uneven scoring totals. He has reached double-digit assists in three of his last five games and dipped below six just once in his last nine. As his toe injury slowly loosens its grip, the connective tissue of the Cavs’ offense has followed.
Garland does not simply pass to Allen. He delivers him advantages.
His dribble penetration forces low-man decisions. His hesitation moves collapse nail defenders. His willingness to attack, even when it is not for his own shot, bends coverage just enough to open the dunker spot.
Those moments do not always register as assists, but they are why Allen’s touches tend to come at the rim rather than two steps outside of it.
That dynamic has always been the foundation of their pairing.
Why the league keeps calling
League-wide interest in both Garland and Allen is not new. It has been persistent, bordering on inevitable.
Teams see Garland as a lead guard who can scale up next to stars or scale down as an offensive engine. They see Allen as a defensive anchor who does not need plays called for him, even though it clearly helps when they do.
Cleveland sees something more specific.
The Cavs believe they need Garland’s ability to organize offense without hijacking it, particularly in fourth quarters. They believe they need Allen’s screening, vertical spacing and defensive erasure behind smaller guards. Most importantly, they believe those skills amplify each other in ways that are difficult to replace piecemeal.
That belief survived last season, even as Kenny Atkinson reshaped the rotation.
By pairing Donovan Mitchell more frequently with Evan Mobley, Atkinson accelerated Mobley’s growth and unlocked his first All-Star appearance and an All-NBA second-team selection.
That shift, however, also produced a revealing byproduct: when healthy, the Garland-Allen tandem logged 1,997 minutes together and posted a 121.9 offensive rating, better than the Mitchell-Mobley pairing (119.5).
It was simply efficient.
This season, Garland and Allen have logged just 262 minutes together.
Back in Sync
Due to early-season injuries, Cleveland was forced to experiment with rotations this season. But the team is returning to a rhythm and rotation that produced a historic offense last season.Joshua Gunter, cleveland.com
Returning to form
This season disrupted that rhythm early.
Garland missed the first seven games due to offseason toe surgery, while Allen was sidelined sporadically with hand injuries, forcing Atkinson into temporary adjustments.
Early on, Mobley was tested as an offensive focal point while Mitchell and Allen were the first to hit the bench.
Now, with Garland closer to full mobility and Mobley back in his familiar role after a brief stint off the bench while recovering from a calf injury, the Cavs are circling back to something recognizable.
Monday marked the first time Allen took more than nine shots since Nov. 12, when he erupted for 30 points on 20 attempts against Miami.
That did not happen by coincidence.
“I challenged our guards,” Atkinson said postgame Monday. “We have to do a better job of rewarding our bigs. We haven’t been doing that enough. Got to give them the ball. Over the middle. On the fullback dive. If they don’t touch it, they are not going to be as engaged defensively. It’s how it works.”
That philosophy aligns directly with Garland’s strengths. He attacks the paint more frequently than any Cavalier. His drives trigger drive-kick-swing sequences, but they also create the simplest reads in basketball: drop-offs, lobs and seals.
The simplicity of the read belies the difficulty of the execution, and Garland’s feel, timing and manipulation are what make those passes look second nature and allow the offense to function at its best.
It is why Allen led the league in field-goal percentage last season.
“I think it’s where I’m getting the ball,” Allen said then. “Probably 80 of those shots are dunks. That’s a testament to the guards. They’re giving me the ball in the right spot.”
The mental connection
Basketball is as much a mental game as a physical one, and the Garland-Allen pairing thrives on that invisible layer.
Garland plays with a kind of joy that is infectious. There’s a natural flow in his dribble and his eyes scanning the defense. That composure allows him to deliver passes or lobs with the quiet authority of someone who doesn’t have to think twice.
For Allen, that mental simplicity is everything.
The rim is already a chaotic place, and Allen’s role demands relentlessness. But when the ball comes off Garland’s hands, it carries a trust, a certainty, that allows Allen to operate without hesitation. He doesn’t have to fight mental friction on top of physical defenses. Garland’s poise gives him that freedom.
One’s joy fuels the other’s calm. One’s awareness feeds the other’s instinct.
That subtle, almost invisible harmony is part of why Cleveland hesitates to tamper with the Core Four.
The postseason question
All of this, however, exists under a narrowing lens.
If the Garland-Allen pairing is going to survive beyond this season as part of the Core Four, regular-season harmony will not be enough. Cleveland needs to reach the Eastern Conference finals and credibly push toward the Finals.
The organization believes Garland and Allen serve complementary postseason roles.
Garland feeds offense in tight windows, amplifying Allen’s presence. Allen repays it on the back line, erasing mistakes as opposing teams hunt Garland in switches late in games.
The question is whether that equation holds when possessions slow, spacing shrinks and opponents are willing to live with uncomfortable trade-offs.
Monday night did not answer that question.
But it did remind the Cavs why they keep picking up the phone, then putting it back down.
As long as Garland can keep organizing advantages and Allen can keep turning them into inevitabilities at the rim, Cleveland will continue to believe this pairing is not a liability, but a reason to wait.
This season may determine whether that patience is rewarded — or finally exhausted.