Everton’s January plans rarely arrive quietly, but the suggestion that Ben White could be the answer to a long running right back issue has stirred debate across Merseyside. Credit must go to Peter O’Rourke for first bringing the story into focus, with his succinct update on social media setting the tone for wider discussion.
“Everton are eyeing a move for Arsenal defender Ben White to solve their problematic right-back issue. #EFC #AFC”
Everton are eyeing a move for Arsenal defender Ben White to solve their problematic right-back issue. #EFC #AFC pic.twitter.com/WeRDnp25K7
— Pete O’Rourke (@SportsPeteO) January 11, 2026
The position has been problematic for seasons now, with no successful heir to Coleman yet.
Right Back Remains a Tactical Fault Line
Seamus Coleman’s influence and professionalism remain valued, but injuries and time have inevitably limited his availability. Nathan Patterson, once viewed as the long term solution, hasn’t developed, leaving Moyes to improvise.
Jake O’Brien has been deployed as the first choice RB, which often leaves Everton’s winger isolated and blunts attacking rhythm. In a league that increasingly demands width and overlap, that absence is keenly felt.
Ben White Profile and Arsenal Context
White’s appeal is obvious. At Arsenal, he has predominantly been used as a right-back, despite arriving with a reputation as a centre back. His tactical intelligence, comfort in possession, and experience at the top end of the Premier League tick boxes Everton have struggled to fill.
However, context matters. With Jurrien Timber now favoured, White has been relegated to a squad player. Injuries have played their part, including knee surgery last season and a hamstring issue in December. At £187,500-a-week, any move would demand careful thought.
Loan Logic Versus Long Term Risk
White turns 29 later this year, and Arsenal would“likely want a big fee given their original investment. A loan move feels like the sensible middle ground, offering immediate improvement without long term financial strain.
Our View – EPL Index Analysis
From an Everton supporter’s perspective, this report sparks cautious curiosity rather than outright excitement. Ben White would instantly raise the technical level of the right side, offering calmness on the ball and a clearer link between defence and midfield. Watching Everton struggle to progress play down that flank has been a recurring frustration, so the appeal is understandable.
There is also the Moyes factor. He values reliability, positional discipline, and players who understand game management. White fits that mould. His experience in high pressure environments and title races could quietly lift standards within the squad, particularly in tight away games where Everton often retreat too deep.
That said, the wages loom large. £187,500-a-week feels uncomfortable for a club still trying to reset its financial footing. Supporters have seen this story before, short term fixes that complicate long term planning. With White’s injury record noted, committing heavily would feel like repeating old mistakes.
A loan, even a short one, would be easier to justify. It buys time, improves balance, and allows Patterson or another option space to develop without pressure. Everton fans are not asking for glamour signings, they are asking for coherence. If White can provide that without mortgaging the future, then the interest makes sense. If not, prudence should prevail.