Aston Villa had a clear opening in front of them on Sunday, and it slipped away. With Arsenal out in front and Manchester City losing the day before, Villa knew what a win would have meant. Instead, they lost 1-0 at home to Everton, and the mood around Villa Park turned flat long before the final whistle. Jamie Redknapp called it “an incredible opportunity” missed. It felt like one too.
EVERTON STRIKE EARLY AND NEVER LET VILLA SETTLE
Everton started faster, sharper, and more direct. They even hit the post inside the opening minutes, which said plenty about the tone of the game. Villa looked like a team expecting to grow into it. Everton did not allow that.
Thierno Barry scored the only goal of the match, and it was enough. Once Everton went ahead, they played with purpose. They stayed compact and waited for Villa to make the game easier for them. Villa never really changed the picture.
REDKNAPP SAYS VILLA “BLEW” THEIR MOMENT
Redknapp did not sugar-coat it after the match. He felt Villa failed across the pitch.
“They have blown an incredible opportunity to put some real pressure on Arsenal,” he said, pointing to the way Villa lacked quality and urgency. He also mentioned how Villa “didn’t have the capabilities in any area today,” and that the usual individuals who rescue them were not at their best.
Villa could have cut Arsenal’s lead to four points with a win. Instead, the gap stays at seven. And it feels bigger than that.
LOSING McGINN AND LACKING OPTIONS DID NOT HELP
Villa also lost John McGinn during the match, and Redknapp suggested that knocked them further off balance. McGinn is one of the players who sets tone. When he is missing, Villa can look a little quieter.
The bigger issue was what came after. Villa’s bench did not look like a bench built for a title chase. There was a lack of attacking options. A lack of energy to change the game. It became clear as the match wore on.
MALEN EXIT QUESTIONED AFTER “STRANGE” DECISION
One of Redknapp’s sharpest points was about Donyell Malen leaving for Roma last week. He called it a “really strange decision,” especially when you looked at the lack of options available.
That is where Villa’s planning gets questioned. January can create opportunities, but it can also create regrets. When you lose a game like this and the bench looks thin, every recent decision gets brought back up. Villa did not just lose points. They lost flexibility.
MOYES GETS CREDIT FOR A HUGE RESULT
Redknapp also made sure to give credit to David Moyes. Everton’s approach was not complicated, but it was effective. They were organised, worked hard and made Villa’s best areas feel crowded.
Redknapp called it a magnificent performance and described it as Everton’s best result of the season. Everton have had mixed spells, but this was a statement win. Away from home. Against a team chasing the top. They looked like a side that knew exactly what they wanted.
KEY EVERTON PLAYERS STEP UP
Redknapp singled out James Garner in midfield, saying he was excellent. Harrison Armstrong also received praise, along with Jack Grealish for keeping width and adding quality on the ball. It felt like Everton had more players on top of their game than Villa did. That is often what decides matches like this. Not tactics. Just who wins their duels and keeps their head.
After the match, Garner explained Everton’s plan clearly. Block the middle. Close the passing lanes. Force Villa wide. Then wait for the moment. They waited. They took it.
AUTHOR’S INSIGHT
This felt like one of those afternoons Villa will regret more later than they do right now. Arsenal were there to be pressured. City had dropped points. Villa had the stage. And they never really showed up. Everton deserved the win, but Villa’s performance made it easier than it should have been. In a title race, these are the days that don’t just hurt. They linger.
As featured on GoonerNews.com