Paul Scholes, a Manchester United legend, has stirred up debate in the football world. He recently said that if Arsenal wins the Premier League this season, they would be the worst team to ever lift the trophy. This comment comes as Arsenal leads the league, but Scholes questions their quality.
What Paul Scholes Said?
In a podcast appearance, Paul Scholes did not hold back. He stated, “If Arsenal win the league, this could be the worst team to win the league.” He argued that Arsenal’s attack lacks firepower and that only one player, like Declan Rice, might make the team of the season. Scholes compared them unfavorably to past champions, saying they do not match the greatness of teams like Manchester United’s 2008 side or other dominant winners.
The Context Behind the Claim
Arsenal is currently four points clear at the top of the Premier League table. Under manager Mikel Arteta, they have built a solid defense and midfield. However, their goal-scoring has been a weak point this season. They rely on set pieces and counter-attacks rather than dominant open-play goals.
Scholes made these remarks after analyzing recent games. He pointed out that Arsenal’s style is more about grinding out results than overwhelming opponents. “Is Arsenal a great team right now? No… you can’t say that until they win trophies,” he added. This comes amid a tight title race with teams like Manchester City and Liverpool pushing hard.
The comment also ties into broader discussions about the Premier League’s competitiveness. This season has seen upsets and lower goal tallies, leading some to question if the overall quality is down.
Reactions from Fans and Experts
Scholes’ words have sparked backlash, especially from Arsenal supporters. On social media, many called it “bitter” and pointed to United’s poor form in recent years. One fan post said, “Everyone in the EPL is up against Arsenal, and Scholes is just salty.”
Experts have mixed views. Jamie Carragher, a Liverpool legend, disagreed, saying Arsenal’s consistency deserves praise. Others, like those on podcasts, echoed Scholes, noting Arsenal’s attack needs improvement. Media outlets like the Daily Mail highlighted how Scholes tore into the Gunners, claiming they’d be the worst champions.
Arsenal’s Current Performance
Despite the criticism, Arsenal has impressed many. They have the best defense in the league, conceding few goals. Players like William Saliba and Gabriel form a strong backline, while Martin Ødegaard pulls strings in midfield.
Up front, issues persist. Strikers have not been prolific, leading to reliance on team goals. Arteta has focused on organization and resilience, which has kept them ahead. The recent wins show grit, but Scholes argues it’s not enough for “greatness.”
If they win, it would end a 22-year drought since their Invincibles season in 2004. That team went unbeaten, a far cry from today’s side.
🗣️Paul Scholes with an outrageous take: “If #Arsenal win the league, this could be the worst team to win the league. If you’re thinking of picking a team of the season and picking the front four, nobody from the Arsenal team gets in that.
“Look at previous champions –… pic.twitter.com/GJyn7Ti5DE
— Arsenal News Channel (@Arsenalnewschan) January 27, 2026
Comparing to Past Champions
Scholes’ claim invites comparisons. Past winners like Manchester City’s centurions (100 points in 2018) or United’s treble winners (1999) set high bars. Even Leicester’s 2016 miracle had flair with players like Jamie Vardy.
Arsenal’s projected points might be lower than some champions. For instance, United’s 2013 title came with 89 points, but they dominated. If Arsenal wins with around 85-90 points, critics like Scholes say it reflects a weaker league.
Looking Ahead
Scholes’ bold statement adds spice to the title race. Whether Arsenal proves him wrong remains to be seen. If they lift the trophy, debates about their legacy will rage on. For now, it motivates the team to silence doubters.
In football, opinions like this keep the passion alive. Arsenal fans hope their side writes a new chapter, not as the “worst,” but as worthy champions.
More on ARSENAL:
Follow Six Sports on