[C](https://www.foxnews.com/sports/mavericks-coach-jason-kidd-unleashes-expletive-filled-defense-cooper-flagg-usage-during-press-conference)ooper Flagg was expected to be an elite defender and an adequate offensive performer when he got to the NBA, but he’s way outperformed expectations. Kevin Garnett said this: “We haven’t had a badass, cold ass white boy like this in a long time.”
Dwight Howard said this: “49 points as a 19-year-old. That’s amazing to see. I know how hard it is to play at this level, and I’m so proud of the young kid. And Jason Kidd for taking a chance and putting him at the point guard position at a young age and letting him learn the game, and he’s just doing a great job, and I’m really proud of his growth and the effort that he’s playing with. Keep it up, young fella, keep it up.”
For his part, Kidd said this: “He’s not about numbers, he’s about wins and losses. That’s who he is. He competes to win… For a young man who thinks that way, he’s gonna be a champion sooner than later. He continues to keep working. For him to be out (with injury) then to be able to come back with this type of game… He’s just competitive and he tried to will his team into a win tonight.”
NBA columnist Brian Windhorst said this: “I’ve seen three teenagers before Flagg who have been blown away impressive to me. LeBron, Luka, and Wembanyama. The way Cooper controls the game on both ends of the floor, the only one he compares to is LeBron.”
He’s gotten a lot of high praise from some pretty impressive people. Not, however, from Jamal Mashburn.
If you haven’t seen it, here’s what Mashburn and Udonis Haslem had to say about Flagg:
If you don’t want to watch the whole video, basically Mashburn says that Flagg “has holes in his game” and that if he came out this year, he would take him sixth after, presumably, Darryn Peterson of Kansas, AJ Dybantsa of BYU, Duke’s Cameron Boozer, UNC’s Caleb Wilson and maybe Kingston Flemings of Houston and Nate Ament of Tennessee.
That made us think two things: first, good thing he’s not a GM and second, is he still mad about losing to Duke in 1992?
That Laettner thing dies hard.
It’s hard to know what exactly to make of it. There’s no question that Peterson, if his health is good, should excel. Dybantsa looks like a lead-pipe cinch. Boozer gets some criticism over his lack of verticality, but so did his dad. And Boozer’s all-around offensive game is brilliant.
Wilson is immensely promising but his offensive skill set isn’t overly polished yet.
For his part, Haslem said he’d prefer to build around VJ Edgecombe over Flagg or Knueppel, but Edgecombe has a pretty good team around him right now and by most accounts, he’s in third place in the Rookie of the Year race. Obviously that can change but still. He’s got a chance right now to make his team great and it’s average.
Look, we know a few former NBA players read this site on occasion. Like Mashburn and Haslem, they’ve been there and know things most of us don’t know and will never know. It reminds us a bit of [Kidd at this presser,](https://x.com/GrantAfseth/status/2017816270154903763?s=20) where he told the writers they were idiots who didn’t know the league and he did. He played at a high level and he knew what he was talking about.
That’s why we don’t criticize Jon Scheyer when things don’t live up to our expectations. Not only does he know way more than we ever will, but look at what none of us know. You can’t possibly know the minor injuries, the psychological pluses and minuses, who really works well together and who just got dumped by his girlfriend. There was a stretch in his junior season when Jason Williams had some emotional issues to deal with. Same, we think, for Grayson Allen when he had his kicking issues. How do any of us know how to approach the complex emotions everyone has and how they affect individuals, much less the team?
So yes, Mashburn and Haslem are inevitably better informed than most of us are. You can’t dismiss their opinions completely.
But if you’re reading here, you’ve seen Flagg for at least a year and half now and you’ve seen how fast he has improved in the league. You’ve seen him blow past NBA legends since he was on the Select Team.
Even NBA pros can get it wrong. Boozer’s dad was a second-round pick who went on to a tremendous NBA career. No one understood how good Mark Price was. It’s unfathomable that Nikola Jokic was a second-round pick. Most recently, people were very dubious about the Charlotte Hornets taking Kon Knueppel with the fourth pick in last summer’s draft.
Those guys can think what they want. We can all check back in a few years and see if they were right.