The New York Knicks have spent the better part of two years positioning themselves for a moment like this. They have deep pockets, flexible contracts, and a roster good enough to dream big. The Giannis Antetokounmpo chatter is real. However, so is the risk of waiting too long while the rest of the East sharpens its knives. If the Knicks don’t land Giannis by the February 5 deadline, standing still would be the most dangerous choice of all. This roster needs true stability, depth, and a second unit that can survive playoff minutes. There is one trade that does exactly that. Because when the whale swims past, precision matters.
Fragile core
Jan 10, 2025; New York, New York, USA; New York Knicks center Karl-Anthony Towns (32) and guards Jalen Brunson (11) and Miles McBride (2) watch from the bench during the fourth quarter against the Oklahoma City Thunder at Madison Square Garden. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images
Brad Penner-Imagn Images
At 31-18, the Knicks enter deadline week as one of the East’s most complete teams on paper. They are also one of its most volatile in practice. Winning the NBA Cup in December validated the Mike Brown hire. It also confirmed that this is no longer a “cute” Knicks team but a real contender. The offense has been elite, ranking third in efficiency. They are driven by Jalen Brunson’s control of tempo and Karl-Anthony Towns’ spacing and rebounding.
Defensively, the Knicks remain strong, but cracks have appeared. The early-January 2-9 skid exposed a rotation stretched too thin and overly dependent on the starters to win non-Brunson minutes. When the shots stop falling, New York doesn’t have a pressure release valve.
Bench problem
Despite the summer addition of Jordan Clarkson, the Knicks remain near the bottom of the league in bench scoring. Injuries to Mitchell Robinson have compounded the issue. This has forced Towns into exhausting defensive assignments and limited lineup creativity. The result is a team good enough to win 50 games. That said, this unit may not be resilient enough to win four playoff rounds.
This is where the Knicks’ season will be decided. Detroit has depth. Boston has depth. Even Cleveland’s regression still comes with waves of playable bodies. New York has six men it trusts. That just isn't enough in May.
Less Giannis, more pragmatism
While Giannis remains the fantasy, league insiders have cooled expectations around a Knicks mega-bid. Draft capital is tight, and there is real reluctance to disrupt a group that already lifted hardware. Instead, the whispers have shifted toward rotation fixes and internal tension management.
Towns’ name popping up in summer talks has reportedly left scars. Robinson's injury cycle has reopened debates about durability versus reliability. Leon Rose’s recent behavior, which hasbeen quiet, methodical, and value-driven, suggests the Knicks are preparing a Plan B that strengthens the roster without blowing it up.
The one trade New York must make
The “Second unit salvation”
Knicks receive: Ayo Dosunmu, Andre Drummond, Trendon Watford, Eric Gordon
76ers receive:, Mitchell Robinson, 2026 first-round pick (via Bulls), 2026 second-round pick (Knicks), 2028 second-round pick (Knicks)
Bulls receive: Guerschon Yabusele, Justin Edwards, 2027 second-round pick (via 76ers)
This is not a headline trade. It’s a championship-grade three-team trade.
The financials: Escaping the apron trap
The Knicks are operating just inches below the Second Apron. This deal is engineered with surgical precision.
Outgoing:
Mitchell Robinson ($12.9M)
Guerschon Yabusele ($5.5M)
Total: ~$18.4M
Incoming:
Ayo Dosunmu ($7.5M)
Andre Drummond ($5.0M)
Eric Gordon ($2.3M)
Trendon Watford ($2.4M)
Total: ~$17.2M
Article Continues Below
The result: compliance with hard-cap rules and additional breathing room. That margin matters when every 10-day contract and injury replacement could trigger penalties.
Why the Knicks must do it
Depth over dreams:
If Giannis doesn’t come, New York’s title path depends on surviving non-Brunson minutes. This deal turns two rotation players into four playable postseason pieces. The Knicks stop bleeding when the starters sit.
The Dosunmu-Watford defensive punch:
Dosunmu gives New York elite point-of-attack defense and off-ball intelligence. Watford is the quiet gem. He is 6’8, switchable, and capable of initiating offense from the elbow. Together, they transform the second unit from passive to predatory.
Drummond as structural insurance:
Robinson’s availability is always theoretical. Drummond’s rebounding and physicality are not. He allows Tom Thibodeau to protect Towns, experiment with jumbo lineups, and survive foul trouble without panic.
Eric Gordon’s playoff gravity:
Gordon’s numbers may be modest, but his reputation isn’t. If he's healthy, defenses still hug him. That spacing alone unlocks cleaner looks for everyone else when games slow down.
Why Philadelphia and Chicago agree
Philadelphia finally gets a true rim protector behind Joel Embiid. They also secure a 2026 Bulls first-rounder. That's one of the most valuable non-lottery-adjacent picks on the market.
Chicago continues its youth pivot. They will convert an expiring Dosunmu into developmental upside and future seconds that align with a longer timeline.
Here's an uncomfortable truth for Nw York, though: the pick hurts Giving up the 2026 Bulls first-rounder is painful. In a deep draft, that could be a top-10 selection. Still, this is the cost of contention. The Knicks are chasing Detroit now. Depth is the currency of playoff survival, and this trade buys it in bulk.
Championships are built in margins
New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11) watches as center Karl-Anthony Towns (32) celebrates after making a three point basket to clinch a win against the Toronto Raptors near the end of the fourth quarter at Scotiabank Arena.
John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images
If Giannis Antetokounmpo doesn’t become a Knick, the season doesn’t end. It may actually clarify. This potential three-team trade doesn’t chase a fantasy. Instead, it's meant to fix reality.
The Knicks must remember that they don’t need another star to win the East. They need just eight players they trust.
This deal gives them nine.