Anyone who has watched the NBA for a few years knows not to overreact to career nights. It’s immensely fun to watch someone perform at or near the peak of their abilities, but it often doesn’t mean much. Those outlier games are often a combination of opportunity, circumstances, and a little luck.
Recently, the Jazz’s backup point guard, Isaiah Collier, dropped 22 dimes on the Pacers. Only John Stockton has had more in a game for the franchise. Does that mean Collier is as good as Stockton? Obviously not. He just got to play all 48 minutes for a shorthanded team, and it’s unlikely he will ever log 20 helpers again in his career, while Stockton has several such performances despite playing in a slow-paced era. It’s still impressive. It was fun. It shows that Collier can be a prolific playmaker given the opportunity. But extrapolating that night and projecting stardom for him would be as silly as believing Julian Champagnie’s 11 three-pointers in a game means he’s the second coming of Reggie Miller. Cautious optimism after career nights is warranted, but sometimes Corey Brewer will drop 51 before returning to his normal career path.
The point here is that Stephon Castle’s 40-12-12 historic triple-double doesn’t need to be assigned special meaning. It can just be enjoyed for what it was: an electrifying performance from one of the league’s best young players. For fringe guys or role players, career nights can be used as a reminder that they can produce more in better circumstances. They can even, often retroactively, serve as signs that there was more to their game than originally thought. Sandro Mamukelashvili’s explosion against the Knicks late last season might have shown that he was ready to make the leap as a shooter we’ve seen from him in Toronto. But Castle doesn’t need to prove anything. He showed star potential as a rookie and has produced like one as a sophomore. If he had finished with, say, a 25-7-8 stat line, the Spurs and their fans should have been just as excited about his future.
With the Castles of the NBA world, it’s the little things, the boring stuff that arguably matters more. The basketball nerds among us will remember the windmill dunk, but also how the Mavericks tried putting their center on him to start the game and then played off of him, daring him to shoot, and how he made them pay by both making threes and, more encouragingly, making quick decisions like stepping into a mid-range jumper or trying a pitch pass and then screen for one of his teammates. The highlights will show him skying for a monster putback dunk, but not necessarily the consistent defensive effort and intensity he displayed all game, a trait that could make him one of the premier two-way forces in the league.
Castle did Castle things against the Mavericks, the kind of spectacular, winning plays he’s made routinely this season. He just did more of it, and in a way that made a random February game one of the most fun Spurs viewing experiences of the last few years. It’s incredibly entertaining to witness amazing performances as they happen and completely fine to feel giddy about them as we rewatch the highlights the next day. But fortunately, Stephon Castle has done enough already that he doesn’t need the help of any arbitrary statistical performance to give anyone a reason to be optimistic or show he could be a legitimate star, likely sooner rather than later.