How Sheffield United are learning lessons of costly transfer mistakes after important recruitment reset
The career of one of Sheffield United’s infamous failed AI transfer gambles has gone full circle after he returned to his homeland of Peru just over a year after making the shock move to Bramall Lane - with United seemingly making moves to ensure they learn the lessons from their costly mistakes.
The Blades memorably made a clutch of data-driven wildcard signings under the influence of former transfer ‘guru’ James Bord. Nigerian wingers Christian Nwachukwu and Ehije Ukaki joined fellow wideman Jefferson Caceres of Peru in South Yorkshire last year, while Bulgarian right-back Mihail Polendakov also made the move from Bord’s Septemvri Sofia.
By that point Caceres had already been sacrificed to free up a space on United’s wildcard roster for defender Nils Zatterstrom, moving to another club co-owned by Bord in Scottish side Dunfermline. Zatterstrom has also since departed, joining Serie A side Genoa on a loan-to-buy deal.
If you’re still following that particular transfer merry-go-round, with Nwachukwu and Ukaki also having since been farmed out on loan to Turkish second-tier side Serikspor and Greek Super League club Atromitos respectively, then it rather sums up the chaos that was United’s muddled transfer policy after Bord was handed de-facto control of it.
That period is now well and truly over, with the former poker player instead switching his attentions to trying to get a bid for United’s rivals Wednesday over the line, but the hangover remains and Caceres’ spell at Scotland has now also come to an end.
A statement from Dunfermline confirmed that the winger “has rejoined his former club FC Melgar back in his homeland” after informing the club that he was keen to return home. Dunfermline subsequently “facilitated the move to Peru in an undisclosed deal.”
Inside Sheffield United’s plan to avoid a repeat of costly transfer mistakes after following Liverpool’s lead
It is unclear if United will receive any benefit from that particular agreement, having initially paid a significant sum to sign Caceres and then selling him to Dunfermline for a fee understood to be a fair bit lower.
The suggestion is that Caceres struggled to settle in Scotland after effectively being packed off north of the border by United, with the language barrier and homesickness impacting his hopes of succeeding with Neil Lennon’s side.
That scenario highlights the inherent flaw in United’s previous transfer plan, which seemed to rely too much on the data and analytics and not enough on the human eye and basic understanding of footballers as people.
I remember vividly watching Caceres’ debut for the United U21s at Shirecliffe not long after he had arrived at United, more out of curiosity than anything. He played on the left wing against a young Fleetwood Town XI and hit the bar before scoring but he looked anything but comfortable as the February wind swirled and the rain absolutely lashed down.
The homeland he had left was in the height of summer and you wondered even then how this could be an arrangement that could ever work, for any party. Numbers and data can only tell you so much; what cannot be quantified, about a player’s character and even simple things like how they will settle on a different continent, is often more important.
Thankfully the penny seems to have dropped at Bramall Lane. They have moved on from Bord’s Short Circuit and engaged a new data company, with a better reputation and more experience working in English football - including with Liverpool during the Jurgen Klopp era.
United are the only Championship club they are allowed to work with, the hope being that it gives the Blades another competitive edge in the second tier. Recruitment staff and boss Chris Wilder also have their input which, considering they are the ones who will have to work with these players, seems rather sensible.
“It's the way the sport's going,” said chief executive Stephen Bettis recently. “A lot of it's data-driven, analytical stuff now, and that massively helps with recruiting from abroad. Because their databases are so vast and we can literally tap into players from all over the world with it.
“If we have belief and confidence in what they [the data company] is pushing out, then it makes it a hell of a lot easier for us to recruit from abroad. I think when you look at the summer, we did recruit some young players from abroad who haven't, at this point in time, worked out, and have gone out on loan to further develop.
“But my question was always around the weighting of the leagues. You can be Ronaldo in certain leagues in the world where the standard just isn’t as high as what we're playing and competing at in the Championship.
“So then you've got to discount certain levels of their ability for how they'll perform at the level of the Championship. We were challenging that in the summer and not really getting the answers that we wanted.
“But with the new guys, they're very clear. They sit and explain how they do weight the leagues, so that we understand their abilities far better. So I think it will certainly assist us. I think there's always risk with foreign players just due to the nature of: will they settle in the UK? Will they settle with their families?
“Will they be happy with the culture and the experience? So I definitely think it comes with a slight risk. But at the same time, there's the ability to potentially get them at a cheaper price.
“So it's definitely something that we should be exploring and considering. And I think you will see more of that with this data analytics company that we're working with.”
Continue Reading