Keon Coleman
Getty
Buffalo Bills wide receiver Keon Coleman has been a topic of conversation since Terry Pegula's end-of-season comments.
The Buffalo Bills may have reached the end of the road for wide receiver Keon Coleman, with one analyst suggesting they trade him for an upgrade at wide receiver.
The second-year receiver struggled in 2025, being benched twice for disciplinary issues and failing reach his previous levels of production. He was also the target for team owner Terry Pegula in his season-ending press conference, with Pegula insisting that it was former head coach Sean McDermott who insisted on drafting Coleman.
Amid the uncertainty of his future in Buffalo, Bleacher Report’s Gary Davenport suggested it could be time for the Bills to trade Coleman and seek a more seasoned wide receiver.
Davenport suggested the Bills could package Coleman with a fifth-round pick and ship him to the Indianapolis Colts for wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. and a sixth-round pick.
“Pittman hasn’t been as productive the past two seasons as he was earlier in his career, but the seventh-year veteran has a pair of 1,000-yard seasons on his NFL resume,” Davenport wrote. “Even if he’s not the true ‘alpha’ wideout the Buffalo Bills so badly need, he’d be a sizable upgrade to the team’s passing-game weapons. He’d also likely be amenable to an extension that would drop his cap hit in 2026.”
Davenport noted that the Bills are in desperate need of a boost for their wide receiving corps, while the Colts would save $24 million against the cap by trading Pittman, a win-win for both teams.