Aaron Rodgers, Pittsburgh Steelers
Getty
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers
After months of radio silence from him, legendary quarterback Aaron Rodgers joined The Pat McAfee Show on Wednesday to chat about how his offseason has been going. Set to become an unrestricted free agent on March 11th at 42 years of age after a rebirth season with the Pittsburgh Steelers, the four-time MVP was honest in his interview. However, he declined to set a timetable for a decision regarding a potential return in 2026.
Following Rodgers’ appearance, ESPN insider Adam Schefter joined The Pat McAfee Show on Thursday to react to what the former champion had to say. The longtime reporter showed a little frustration after not getting an answer from Rodgers on whether or not he would come back for his 22nd career season.
Adam Schefter Expected an Answer From Pittsburgh Steelers Quarterback Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers
GettyIn 2025, Aaron Rodgers helped former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin secure a winning season for a 19th consecutive season.
While many, including Schefter, were hoping for an answer from Rodgers on his future, the all-time great did not answer whether or not he would return to Pittsburgh in 2026. So, Schefter was seemingly a little frustrated with the situation. Here is what he had to say during his Pat McAfee Show appearance on Thursday:
“Everyone wanted to know, is he playing or is he not? He didn’t really give any indication.”
While Schefter and many more reporters might be a little upset about Rodgers taking his time and enjoying his offseason, that is exactly what is taking place. However, a decision could arrive soon with the NFL’s free agency period set to officially begin on March 11th.
A Return to Pittsburgh Makes the Most Sense for Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers celebrating a win over the Baltimore Ravens at Acrisure Stadium after the Pittsburgh Steelers clinched the AFC North division.
GettyIf Aaron Rodgers were to play in 2026, it would be his 22nd NFL season.
While his future remains up in the air, Rodgers returning to the Steel City for a second season there could be the most likely outcome. This may be the case because of how he performed this past season, along with the organization deciding to hire his former head coach from his time in Green Bay, Mike McCarthy.
In 2025, on a new team and battling a fractured wrist, Rodgers showed the kind of grit and toughness that the fans of Pittsburgh know all too well. He recorded a respectable 25 total touchdowns and just seven interceptions en route to helping the team win the AFC North for the first time since the 2020 season. Without his consistency and leadership, it is hard to say if the team would have had the same amount of success.
With McCarthy coming into the fold after Mike Tomlin decided to step down after a legendary 19-year run, Rodgers now has another opportunity to play for a winning head coach. However, the difference between McCarthy and Tomlin is that Rodgers’ time with the Super Bowl-winning head coach goes all the way back to 2006.
After being named the starter of the Packers back in 2008, Rodgers, thanks to McCarthy’s leadership, would go on to lead the team to eight playoff appearances, five division titles, three NFC Championship game appearances, and that aforementioned Super Bowl victory before the organization ended up parting ways with McCarthy in 2018. Nevertheless, their history is strong, and it could convince Rodgers to return for at least one more run.