Lamine Yamal (5/10):
Those who turned up at St. James' Park hoping to see flashes of genius from the teenager would have left disappointed. Yamal was pretty much marked out of the game by Lewis Hall but he still had the final say thanks to Thiaw's trip on Olmo. Credit where it's due, though, for a very composed spot-kick.
Robert Lewandowski (3/10):
A tough performance to watch from one of the finest centre-forwards of all time. Lewandowski looked off the pace all evening, and also occasionally muscled off the ball. Got one big chance in the second half but unsurprisingly squandered it.
Raphinha (4/10):
An unusually quiet evening for the Brazilian, who only created one proper chance, for Lewandowski. Truth be told, it was something of a surprise that he stayed on the field for the entire 90 minutes and Flick will probably wish he'd have taken Raphinha off, given he lost Barnes for the game's opening goal.