Josh Hart, New York Knicks
Photo by Elsa/Getty Images
Josh Hart, New York Knicks
New York Knicks outspoken guard Josh Hart delivered a blunt message to ESPN’s Stephen A. Smith, escalating a public back-and-forth over criticism involving both Hart and teammate Mikal Bridges.
The exchange followed Smith’s comments on ESPN’s First Take, where he criticized the Knicks’ roster decisions and questioned Bridges’ recent performance.
“For me, I think Stephen A., as a part-time Knicks fan, needs to shut the hell up,” Hart said, via Newsday’s Steve Popper. “He barely knows guys that are on the team.”
Hart’s response came after Smith publicly pushed back on his defense of Bridges, turning what began as a routine postgame remark into a broader discussion about expectations, production and the price New York paid to acquire the veteran wing.
Hart Defends Bridges Amid Recent Struggles
Bridges has faced increased scrutiny following a dip in production since the All-Star break. Over his last 18 games, he has averaged 10.8 points, 3.7 rebounds and 3.4 assists, including an eight-game stretch this month in which he reached double figures just twice.
Hart pointed to role and usage rather than performance as the source of the criticism.
“Last year, he didn’t have many plays called for him. This year, he probably has even less plays called for him,” Hart said, via Stefan Bondy of the New York Post. “So obviously there’s a mental hurdle he needs to get through… I think he gets some of that unfair flak just because he’s doing what’s asked of him.”
Stephen A. Smith Pushes Back
Smith responded on First Take with a direct message aimed at Hart, dismissing the Knicks guard’s comments and shifting the focus toward accountability.
“I need Josh Hart to be quiet. Sit down,” Smith said. “Only time I want you standing up and talking is if you’re playing… You need to stand down. This is grown-ups. This is business.”
While acknowledging that Bridges is capable of more and may be working through a slump, Smith emphasized that expectations surrounding the situation go beyond individual production.
Trade Cost Drives the Debate
At the center of the discussion is the price the Knicks paid to acquire Bridges — a package that included multiple first-round draft assets and immediately raised expectations for the team’s ceiling.
Smith pointed directly to that cost in explaining why criticism has intensified.
“Seven picks. Seven,” Smith said. “But do they think he even gives you ten points a game? That’s unacceptable.”
He added that the deal will ultimately be judged by results, particularly if the Knicks fall short of reaching the NBA Finals and suggested that such a package could have positioned the franchise to pursue other star-level talent like Milwaukee Bucks‘ two-time MVP Giannis Antetokounmpo.
Pressure Builds Around Knicks Expectations
The exchange reflects the pressure surrounding the Knicks as expectations continue to rise late in the season.
Hart’s response represents a locker-room perspective centered on team roles and internal support. Smith’s criticism, meanwhile, focuses on production, cost and the demands that come with competing in New York.
For Bridges, the focus remains on consistency and fit within the offense. For the Knicks, the question is whether the investment will translate into postseason success and how quickly.