The New York Jets are drawing attention as discussions around player value continue across the NFL. Wide receiver Garret Wilson, one of the team’s brightest stars, has unexpectedly entered that conversation.
Wilson has been labeled the most overpaid player on the Jets’ roster entering the 2026 season. The assessment has sparked debate given his status as a key offensive weapon and fan favorite.
New York Jets, Garrett Wilson, NFL
Despite being picked up by Dallas Cowboys cornerback Daron Blan D (26) near the end zone, Wide receiver Garrett Wilson (5) was able to get the ball into the end zone for a fourth quarter touchdown, Sunday, October 5, 2025.
Wilson has quickly established himself as one of the league’s most dynamic receivers since arriving in New York. His route running, hands and ability to create separation have made him a focal point in the Jets’ passing attack.
Despite that production, the discussion centers on the size of his contract compared to overall team impact. Evaluators have questioned whether his salary aligns with the level of consistent elite output typically expected at that price point.
NFL Analysis Names Garrett Wilson as New York Jets’ Most Overpaid Player
New York Jets, Garrett Wilson, NFL
Oct 5, 2025; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Wide receiver Garrett Wilson (5) catches the ball during warm ups before the game against the Dallas Cowboys at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Wilson has been named as New York’s most overpaid player. This is detailed more in an analysis by Brad Gagnon for Bleacher Report.
He’s still technically cheap for now, but that four-year, $130 million extension kicks in next year and Wilson’s $32.5 million AAV ranks sixth at the position. The talent and potential are undeniable, but this is still a guy who has never put up 1,200 yards or eight touchdowns in a single season and is making borderline Justin Jefferson money.
The Jets are in a pivotal stage as they look to contend in a competitive AFC landscape. Managing financial commitments while maximizing on-field performance remains critical as the organization builds around its core players.
As the season approaches, Wilson’s performance will be under increased scrutiny. His ability to deliver at a high level could reshape the narrative and reaffirm his importance to the Jets’ long-term plans.