The Buffalo Bills are undecided on whether O.J. Simpson will appear on the Legend Wall at the new Highmark Stadium opening this summer in Orchard Park.
Getty
Will the Buffalo Bills honor O.J. at the new Highmark Stadium?
O.J. Simpson has been on the Buffalo Bills‘ Wall of Fame since 1980 — but as the franchise prepares to open its over $2.1 billion new stadium this summer, his spot on the Legend Wall isn’t guaranteed, and the fan debate is already loud.
Bills senior vice president of design Frank Cravotta told ESPN’s Alaina Getzenberg that the design team is “preparing for both possibilities” — meaning the Buffalo Bills could go either way. The new stadium features a “Family Circle” plaza outside with dedications to each Wall of Fame member, plus additional space for names inside the venue.
Buffalo Bills Face an Uncomfortable O.J. Simpson Decision
Simpson’s on-field resume with the Bills isn’t up for debate. He rushed for 10,183 yards across nine seasons in Buffalo, led the league in rushing four times, and became the first player in NFL history to crack 2,000 rushing yards in a single season when he ran for 2,003 yards in just 14 games in 1973. That year, he took home both the NFL MVP and Offensive Player of the Year awards. He was a five-time All-Pro and was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1985.
The problem is everything that came after. Simpson was acquitted in a 1995 criminal trial for murder, but a civil jury found him liable for their deaths in 1997. Then in 2008, he was convicted on armed robbery, kidnapping, and 10 other charges tied to a memorabilia confrontation in Las Vegas. He served nine years in prison. Simpson died in April 2024 at age 76 after a battle with prostate cancer.
Buffalo Bills New Highmark Stadium Near Completion
The timing makes this decision impossible to avoid. The new Highmark Stadium is on track to open this summer, with the Bills expected to take over the building at substantial completion on June 1, according to ESPN. Crews are tearing down the old building across the street, and fans are already scooping up memorabilia from the demolition — including $5,000 urinal troughs that have become a collector obsession.
The Wall of Fame currently has 31 members. Simpson’s name remained on it at the old stadium until the building closed. Whether it carries over to the new one is a question the Bills haven’t answered publicly, and with the facility nearing completion, the clock is ticking.
Every part of the Bills’ 2026 offseason has carried a sense of reset — a new stadium, Josh Allen becoming a father, a franchise turning the page. The Simpson question is the one piece of old business that doesn’t have a clean answer.