Joe Royer and the Cleveland Browns are drawing scrutiny as analysts revisit the team’s 2026 NFL Draft decisions. What looked like a depth move at the time has since been labeled the weakest selection in the class.
The designation centers on value rather than raw ability, with questions surrounding whether the pick addressed a pressing need. Cleveland entered the draft with several areas requiring reinforcement, making the decision to add a tight end a point of discussion among evaluators.
Cleveland Browns, Joe Royer, NFL
Cincinnati Bearcats tight end Joe Royer (11) scores a touchdown as Iowa State Cyclones defensive back Quentin Taylor Jr. (24) attempts to stop him in the first quarter of the NCAA football game between the Cincinnati Bearcats and Iowa State Cyclones at Nippert Stadium in Cincinnati on Oct. 4, 2025.
Royer arrives with a reputation as a physical player who can contribute in blocking situations and short-area roles. His style aligns with a team that values balance and toughness, particularly in offensive schemes that rely on controlling the line of scrimmage.
Even so, the path to immediate impact appears limited due to the existing depth at the position. Established players already occupy key roles, leaving Royer to compete for opportunities while adjusting to the professional level.
NFL Analysis Names Joe Royer as Cleveland Browns’ Worst Pick in 2026 NFL Draft
Cleveland Browns, Joe Royer, NFL
Cincinnati Bearcats tight end Joe Royer (11) gestures after scoring a touchdown in the third quarter of the College Football game between the Cincinnati Bearcats and the Pittsburgh Panthers at Nippert Stadium in Cincinnati on Saturday, Sept. 7, 2024.
Royer was named as Cleveland’s worst pick in the NFL Draft this year. This is detailed more in an analysis by Josh Edwards for CBS Sports.
Worst pick (B-): TE Joe Royer, Cincinnati (Round 5, pick 170)
“The Browns seemed to be caught off-guard by an early run on the tight end position. They eventually address the position, but options were more limited.”
The Browns’ approach suggests a willingness to invest in development, even if the short-term return is uncertain. Late-round picks often carry that profile, with teams betting on growth over time rather than instant production.
Perception can shift quickly once games begin, and Royer now has the opportunity to reshape the narrative. If he finds a role and contributes effectively, the early criticism may fade as Cleveland evaluates the long-term outcome of its draft strategy.