Two years after delivering a Super Bowl to Philadelphia, Jalen Hurts is somehow entering a season that league insiders believe could define whether he remains the face of the Philadelphia Eagles long term.
Since taking over as the Eagles starter in 2021, Hurts has made three Pro Bowls, reached two Super Bowls, won Super Bowl LIX MVP honors, and become one of the league's most dangerous dual-threat weapons.
He helped revolutionize short-yardage football with the Eagles' unstoppable "Tush Push," piled up historic rushing touchdown numbers for a quarterback, and developed into an efficient deep-ball passer.
But Hurts has also remained one of the NFL's most debated stars.
To some, he is a proven winner who elevates his teams in high-pressure moments. To others, he is a quarterback who relies too heavily on system structure, elite roster support, and rushing ability that may not age gracefully.
ESPN's Jeremy Fowler highlighted that divide Thursday after speaking with NFL executives about major storylines entering 2026.
One AFC executive reportedly told Fowler he could envision Philadelphia moving Hurts if the offense disappoints again, calling him a "polarizing player" whose value could decline as his mobility fades.
“Hurts I could see,” when asked whether the Eagles could move on from him. “Polarizing player, and as his running ability starts to decline, his value will decline, too. And (Eagles general manager Howie Roseman) will always be proactive with finding solutions.”
Even Fowler noted how this will be “a crucial year for the Eagles offense under Hurts.”
More news: Joe Burrow's Future in Cincinnati Gets Clearer Ahead of 2026 Season
On the surface, the notion that Philly could trade Hurts away sounds absurd. He literally lifted the Lombardi Trophy just two years ago and was ranked No. 19 in the NFL Top 100 entering last season, sixth among quarterbacks.
But the NFL is a cold place, and Philly is even colder when the pressure starts to climb
Under general manager Howie Roseman, the Eagles have repeatedly moved on from players before emotional attachment or past success could outweigh long-term roster flexibility.
The clearest example came in 2021, when the Eagles traded Carson Wentz just 20 months after signing him to a massive extension, absorbing what was then a record dead-cap hit to reset the franchise around Hurts.
That move eventually helped Philadelphia acquire pieces tied to A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith, and Jalen Carter.
Roseman has also consistently reshaped the roster through aggressive trades, draft maneuvering, and calculated exits from aging veterans.
Philly let Pro Bowlers and key contributors like Javon Hargrave, Chauncey Gardner-Johnson, Haason Reddick, and Miles Sanders walk rather than overpay them, while routinely flipping draft assets to stay ahead of roster decline.
That mindset matters because Hurts' contract structure gives Philadelphia a lot of flexibility.
Hurts signed a five-year, $255 million extension with Philadelphia in 2023 that briefly made him the highest-paid player in NFL history. The deal included roughly $179 million in guarantees and tied him to the franchise through the 2028 season.
But like many modern NFL quarterback contracts, the structure matters more than the headline number.
While moving Hurts before or during the 2026 season would create massive dead-cap penalties, the contract becomes far more manageable afterward, especially through a post-June 1 trade structure.
League insiders have increasingly pointed to 2026 as a pivot point because it is reportedly the last fully guaranteed year of the deal, giving the Eagles the option to move on if they believe the offense has plateaued.
And the warning signs were already there last season.
Despite featuring A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith, and reigning Offensive Player of the Year Saquon Barkley, Philadelphia ranked near the bottom of the league in passing yards (194.3 per game) and scoring offense (22.3 points per game).
Much of the blame was put on Hurts.
The league has seen versions of this before, too.
Russell Wilson went from Super Bowl champion to trade candidate once Seattle hit its ceiling. Jared Goff went to a Super Bowl and was still moved by the Rams. Wentz nearly won MVP before Philadelphia pivoted.
NFL front offices increasingly prioritize sustainability over loyalty, especially when quarterback contracts consume massive cap space.
Hurts could become the latest example if the Eagles' offense doesn't rebound in 2026.
2026 NEWSWEEK DIGITAL LLC.