Ballard's Colts have made playoffs only twice in 8 seasons despite talented rosters.
Ballard excels at drafting stars but struggles to build a consistent Super Bowl contender.
Ballard's conservative free-agency approach preserves cap but leaves roster holes unaddressed.
2026 NFL Scouting Combine
Source: Justin Casterline / Getty
Where Does ChatGPT Rank Chris Ballard Amongst Current NFL GMs
Evaluating NFL general managers is one of the most difficult exercises in football because success depends on a combination of drafting, roster construction, salary cap management, coaching hires, and long-term vision.
While wins and losses ultimately define a front office’s legacy, this ranking also considers process, talent evaluation, and each executive’s ability to build a sustainable contender in today’s NFL.
Take a look below at Where ChatGPT Rank Chris Ballard Amongst Current NFL GMs.
RELATED | Every Contract Extension Given By Chris Ballard As The Colts GM
Howie Roseman — Philadelphia Eagles
Brad Holmes — Detroit Lions
Eric DeCosta — Baltimore Ravens
Les Snead — Los Angeles Rams
Brett Veach — Kansas City Chiefs
Brian Gutekunst — Green Bay Packers
John Lynch — San Francisco 49ers
Brandon Beane — Buffalo Bills
Omar Khan — Pittsburgh Steelers
Jason Licht — Tampa Bay Buccaneers
John Schneider — Seattle Seahawks
Adam Peters — Washington Commanders
Monti Ossenfort — Arizona Cardinals
Kwesi Adofo-Mensah — Minnesota Vikings
Chris Grier — Miami Dolphins
Mickey Loomis — New Orleans Saints
Joe Hortiz — Los Angeles Chargers
Nick Caserio — Houston Texans
Chris Ballard — Indianapolis Colts
Andrew Berry — Cleveland Browns
Mike Borgonzi — Tennessee Titans
Terry Fontenot — Atlanta Falcons
Dan Morgan — Carolina Panthers
John Spytek — Las Vegas Raiders
Ryan Poles — Chicago Bears
Joe Schoen — New York Giants
Duke Tobin — Cincinnati Bengals
Trent Baalke — Jacksonville Jaguars
Eliot Wolf — New England Patriots
Darren Mougey — New York Jets
George Paton — Denver Broncos
Jerry Jones — Dallas Cowboys (de facto GM)
ChatGPT ranked Chris Ballard at No. 19 because he’s one of the NFL’s most polarizing executives:
Why he’s not higher
No AFC South titles since 2020. Despite having a talented roster for several years, the Colts have made the playoffs only twice in Ballard’s eight seasons.
Quarterback instability. After Andrew Luck retired, Ballard cycled through veterans like Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz, Matt Ryan, and Gardner Minshew before drafting Anthony Richardson. The Wentz trade in particular set the franchise back.
Conservative free-agency approach. Ballard has traditionally avoided major free-agent spending, which has preserved cap flexibility but arguably left roster holes unaddressed.
Results matter. At some point, strong drafts and roster depth need to translate into division titles and playoff wins.
Why he’s not lower
Excellent drafter. Ballard has found stars such as Quenton Nelson, Grover Stewart, Jonathan Taylor, EJ Speed, Shaquille Leonard, Zaire Franklin, Josh Downs, and developing lineman.
Strong roster construction outside QB. The Colts have generally been competitive despite instability at the most important position.
Cap management. Indianapolis is rarely in salary-cap trouble and usually retains its homegrown talent.
The simplest summary
Ballard is probably a top-10 talent evaluator but only a middle-tier team builder when judged by overall franchise results.
Love All Sports? Get more! Join the 93.5 / 107.5 The Fan Newsletter
We care about your data. See our privacy policy.
If GMs were broken into tiers, he would land around 15–20, alongside executives who draft well but haven’t consistently produced elite team success. The biggest reason he’s 19th instead of top 10 is that after eight seasons, there are still more questions than answers about whether his roster-building philosophy can produce a legitimate Super Bowl contender.