Brian Schottenheimer did not hand Tyler Guyton the [Cowboys](https://www.sportingnews.com/uk/nfl/dallas-cowboys)' left tackle job this spring. Instead, he opened a competition with Nate Thomas during organized team activities. For a player drafted in the first round only two years ago, that decision says plenty about where he stands entering the 2026 season.
Guyton arrived in Dallas with expectations attached to the position and the draft slot. Jerry Jones used a first-round pick on the former Oklahoma tackle in 2024, viewing him as a long-term answer on the offensive line. Two seasons later, that answer remains incomplete, which helps explain why Schottenheimer chose competition over certainty.
The decision becomes more interesting when listening to Schottenheimer's assessment. He did not question Guyton's physical tools. In fact, he [called him](https://www.dallascowboys.com/news/tyler-guyton-reacts-to-cowboys-opening-up-left-tackle-competition#:~:text=%22Tyler%27s%20biggest%20thing,extremely%20hard%20on.%22) "one of the most athletic big men I've ever been around." That is not the description of a player lacking talent or upside.
Yet Schottenheimer followed that praise with the comment that mattered most. He said, "the consistency has not been there." In a few words, the head coach explained why a former first-round pick is still fighting for the job rather than preparing for the season as the unquestioned starter.
That distinction is important because Dallas already knows what Guyton can look like at his best. The challenge has been producing that level often enough to remove doubt. Until that happens, every strong practice can help his case, while every setback keeps the conversation alive.
Thomas' presence in the competition reinforces that reality. The battle is not about replacing Guyton's talent. It is about determining whether talent alone is enough to trust with one of the offense's most important positions.
Schottenheimer now faces a choice that seemed unlikely when Guyton entered the league. Dallas drafted him to end questions at left tackle. Instead, the head coach enters the summer still searching for the answer.
More NFL news:
--------------