Everton have been ordered to pay an English club a staggering £40 million after The Toffees lost a legal battle over PSR issues this week, with the Premier League continuing to haunt them.
Wednesday afternoon's ruling is an unprecedented legal punishment, just three years after the Merseysiders were handed a 10-point deduction by the Premier League in 2023 after falling foul of regulations in the 2021-22 season.
The punishment was then reduced to six points on appeal at the start of 2024. However, the knock-on effect has continued well beyond then, with the 'what ifs' of Sean Dyche's team of that time now having been taken to court by one club it affected more than the Toffees themselves.
Arsenal Players and Mikel Arteta With the Premier League Trophy Related
How Much Money Every Premier League Club Earned For Final 2025-26 Position
Over £50 million separates 1st and 20th!
Everton Ordered to Pay English Club £40 million
Everton's Hill Dickinson Stadium
Everton's Hill Dickinson Stadium
Burnley argued, as per The Sun, that if the points' deduction happened in 2022 – the year they were relegated – Everton would have gone down instead, leading to further retrospective punishment this week.
Everton finished 16th in the 2021-22 season after picking up 39 points – leaving them just points clear of 18th-placed Burnley. The Clarets believe they missed out on millions as a result of going down a division and the case has now gone in their favour.
The Toffees’ American-based hierarchy, having only taken over the club’s day-to-day running last year, are now looking to appeal the decision in the coming days. The Friedkin Group have made relatively light work of helping the club move past previous grievances, funding the new stadium, reducing debt, and backing Sean Dyche with a squad he has worked hard to shape - but after taking several steps forward, the latest is certainly a step back.
Other Clubs Had Plotted Legal Action Against Everton
the friedkin group
According to The Lawyer, it is suggested that Burnley had sought at least £50m from Everton in compensation, but the reduced ruling will still be detrimental to the club. What's more, clubs including Leicester City, Leeds, Nottingham Forest and Southampton had also planned to bring proceedings against Everton, but later dropped their claims.
The decision is believed to be the first of its kind and will likely have a significant impact on future financial fair play disputes, with clubs that breach rules facing not only a sporting sanction but also the possibility of compensation claims from other clubs. Manchester City and its rivals will be closely following the appeal and any legal precedent it sets.
Several Premier League clubs are understood to have lined up legal counsel to sue City for compensation, should it be found to have breached League rules in the 115 charges case brought against it.