Hincapie was a near-constant presence during the 2025-26 campaign, making 39 appearances across all competitions. His versatility and composure on the ball allowed him to become a key member of a defensive unit that has now conceded the fewest goals in the last three Premier League seasons. His journey in north London began with a clean sheet in a 2-0 Champions League win over Athletic Club, and he never looked back.
While his primary job was keeping clean sheets, the Ecuadorian also chipped in with a crucial goal during a draw at Wolves in February. His individual excellence was frequently recognized by the Emirates faithful, with the defender picking up the Arsenal Player of the Month award in both February and April as the title race reached its fever pitch.