One of the biggest debates among Liverpool supporters this summer concerns squad depth.
Not necessarily who has arrived.
But who is still here.
The return of Harvey Elliott and Kostas Tsimikas has prompted some fans to ask an uncomfortable question:
Has Liverpool’s squad actually improved enough?
Last summer, reports suggested Liverpool were open to moving both players on.
Neither established themselves as regular starters, and loan moves eventually became the solution.
At the time, it appeared the club were preparing to refresh the squad and move in a different direction.
Now, just a year later, both players are back competing for places under Andoni Iraola.
For some supporters, that raises concerns.
The argument is straightforward.
If Liverpool previously felt these players were not central to the club’s plans, then relying on them again could be interpreted as a step backwards rather than forwards.
Supporters hoping for significant strengthening across the squad may view it as evidence that the rebuild is still incomplete.
That is where the phrase “squad regression” has begun to appear in discussions.
There is, however, another way of looking at the situation.
A new manager often changes the outlook for players.
Iraola has no obligation to share the views of the previous coaching staff.
He may believe Elliott and Tsimikas possess qualities that better suit his football.
Managers regularly revive careers that previously appeared to be heading elsewhere.
Football is full of examples of players flourishing under a different coach.
Harvey Elliott remains one of Liverpool’s most technically gifted players.
His creativity, close control and ability to unlock defences have never been in doubt.
The question has always been whether he can consistently influence matches in the role Liverpool need him to play.
If Iraola finds the right position and system for Elliott, the midfielder could yet become an important contributor.
The same applies to Kostas Tsimikas.
While he has often lived in the shadow of Liverpool’s first-choice left-back, he has generally performed reliably when called upon.
His delivery from wide areas, energy and experience mean he still offers useful depth over a demanding season.
The challenge for him is proving he can contribute consistently rather than occasionally.
Ultimately, Liverpool supporters are justified in wanting stronger competition throughout the squad.
Elite teams rarely stand still.
Every transfer window presents an opportunity to improve.
If Liverpool finish the summer relying heavily on players they previously considered moving on, criticism will inevitably grow.
On the other hand, if Iraola can unlock new levels from Elliott, Tsimikas and several other squad players, their return may ultimately be viewed as smart squad management rather than regression.
The answer will not come from what happened last summer.
It will come from what happens on the pitch over the next nine months.
Jamie (The Kopite View)
Related