Miami Dolphins News
We ask Miami Dolphins fans which past player they beieved would be a star for the team but ultimatly were busts.
Jul 21, 2026, 12:00 AM UTC
We’ve all been there—analyzing the latest draft class and speculating on who might become a future star or, at the very least, a solid long-term player for the Miami Dolphins. While our predictions sometimes pan out, they often fall flat. I’m not just talking about high-profile first-round busts, but those late-round picks or undrafted free agents who we just had a gut feeling about. Whether it was based on firsthand knowledge of their college career or a deeper dive into their tape, we all have that one player we were convinced would succeed at the next level, regardless of where they were drafted.
So this evening’s Phinsider Question Of The Day is not necessarily about the team’s biggest bust but more about that one guy that maybe everyone else was overlooking but you hitched your fandom wagon to anyway, and then they seriously let you down.
Please tell us your biggest disappointment in a player either drafted by our Dolphins or signed as an UDFA that never came close to living up to the hype you had in your head for the guy.
Please share your thoughts and answers in the comments section below.
Loading comments
Getting the conversation ready...