Nil Satis Nisi Optimum: The story and evolution of the Everton crest
Few symbols in world football carry the quiet gravitas of the Everton Football Club crest. Not in my view anyway… for what it’s worth.
Grounded in history, locality, and an unwavering commitment to excellence (while often not achieving it), the emblem is far more than a marketing tool. It is an identity forged in the heart of Merseyside.
With the club now located within the grandeur of the Hill Dickinson, the badge will forever offer a continuous link connecting to the grand history of the wonderful Goodison Park.
Yet, the crest as we know it today was not born overnight. Its evolution spans over a century of subtle refinements, minimalist experiments, fan-driven rebellions, and historic restorations.
1. Before the crest (1920s–1930s): The interlocked monogram
For the first four decades following the club’s founding in 1878, Everton shirts did not feature a formal crest. In line with the era, match kits were largely plain royal blue, occasionally adorned with simple white initials.
Caption: Everton’s early 1920s interlocked EFC monogram.
The first true ancestor of club branding arrived in 1920. It featured a bold blue shield containing three white, gracefully interwoven letters: E.F.C. While it lacked the symbolic motifs that define the club today, this minimalist monogram established royal blue as Everton’s primary visual identity.
2. Theo Kelly’s masterstroke (1938–1972): The birth of an icon
The defining moment in Everton’s visual history came in the summer of 1938. Club secretary Theo Kelly was tasked with designing an official club tie to be worn by himself and Chairman Mr. Green.
Caption: Theo Kelly’s original 1938 design featuring Prince Rupert’s Tower, laurel wreaths, and the Latin motto.
After spending four months puzzling over how best to represent the identity of the club, Kelly chose three distinct elements that would change Everton’s branding forever:
Prince Rupert’s Tower: The 18th-century stone lock-up standing on Everton Brow, long associated with the local neighborhood.
The Laurel Wreaths: Classical Greek symbols of victory, honor, and athletic triumph.
The Latin Motto: Nil Satis Nisi Optimum — “Nothing but the best is good enough”.
Kelly’s design—the central tower framed by wreaths inside a shield, topped by the club name and underscored by the motto scroll—became the definitive DNA for every classic Everton badge that followed.
3. The experimental decades (1970s–1980s): Minimalist
Despite Kelly creating the crest in 1938, it took four decades for the tower to regularly feature on matchday kit badges. The 1970s and 1980s were marked by constant experimentation as kit manufacturers embraced bolder, simplified aesthetics:
1972–1978: The club opted for stripped-back text monograms, moving from diagonal cursive letters to a simple, horizontal EFC block typeface.
1978–1982: Everton introduced a bold circular roundel badge—the first time Prince Rupert’s Tower and the motto appeared together on an official match kit.
1983–1991: During the golden era under Howard Kendall, the crest was streamlined for 80s sportswear. The motto was dropped in favor of a clean, modern emblem pairing the tower and laurels with prominent E.F.C. lettering.
Caption: Left: The 1978 roundel badge (the first tower on match kits). Right: The iconic 1980s crest from the club’s title-winning years.
4. Return to heritage & the 2013 fan backlash
By 1991, Everton returned to the classic Theo Kelly shield design, refining it further in 2000 with clean digital outlines, yellow accents, and the addition of the club’s foundation year, 1878.
Then came May 2013.
Caption: The controversial 2013 redesign that omitted “Nil Satis Nisi Optimum” and triggered swift supporter opposition.
In an attempt to modernise the logo for digital platforms, a simplified redesign was unveiled. Crucially, the redesign omitted the laurel wreaths and completely removed the historic Nil Satis Nisi Optimum motto.
The reaction from the Everton fanbase was swift and decisive.
Within 48 hours, over 16,000 supporters signed an online petition demanding the return of the club’s traditional identity.
Recognising the misstep, the club apologised and promised that the controversial badge would only be used for a single transitional season (2013/14) while fans were consulted on a permanent replacement.
The 2013 redesign controversy served as a powerful reminder: a football club’s identity belongs to its supporters.
Caption: The supporter-voted crest introduced in 2014, bridging the history of Goodison Park with the club’s future.
In late 2013, the club held an open fan vote featuring three newly developed designs. Overwhelmingly, supporters selected the crest introduced for the 2014/15 season—a sleek, modern refinement that proudly restored both the laurel wreaths and the Latin motto.
Today, as Evertonians get used to life at their iconic waterfront stadium, the badge serves as a constant.
Styles, kit manufacturers, and stadiums may change, but the core identity forged by Theo Kelly in 1938 remains untouched: Prince Rupert’s Tower, the laurels of victory, and a motto that demands nothing but the best.
Gary is editor for ReadEverton. He has many years experience of sports writing behind him after deciding (belatedly) that the world of accountancy wasn't for him. His work has been featured on (among many others) BBC Sport and The Metro. He has written on many sports, but considers himself an expert in football and F1. When not writing and editing he likes to go to the cinema and sip a lovely cold pint of Guinness (not always at the same time).
View all articles →
dave.sport is in beta
We are building a new home for independent sports coverage. dave.sport is currently in beta, with new features and publisher tools rolling out as we test what fans need most.
Explore the beta
Have Everton finally found their Gana replacement?
Have Everton finally found their Gana replacement?
Gabby Agbonlahor drops hint via a Jack Grealish/Everton joke
Gabby Agbonlahor drops hint via a Jack Grealish/Everton joke