Jonathan Taylor in the middle in a Colts jersey Fireworks in the background
Jonathan Taylor in the middle in a Colts jersey Fireworks in the background
Jonathan Taylor has already proven he can dominate fantasy football when the Colts give him the keys. Now, Indianapolis has given him something even more valuable: certainty. Taylor enters the 2026 season with a new contract and a healthy Daniel Jones returning to stabilize the offense. That combination could make Taylor one of the safest first-round selections on the entire fantasy board. After another monster campaign in 2025, the question really is whether managers will recognize just how favorable the environment around him has become before draft day arrives.
Franchise centerpiece
Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor (28) carries the ball against the Houston Texans during the first half at NRG Stadium.
Troy Taormina-Imagn Images
Drafted back in 2020, Taylor quickly established himself as one of the NFL's premier runners. He had a spectacular 2021 campaign in which he led the league with 1,811 rushing yards and 18 touchdowns. That season cemented his reputation as a rare combination of speed, vision and power. However, Taylor's staying power has been equally important to his fantasy football value.
Over six seasons, he has become the undisputed centerpiece of Indianapolis' offense and has continued climbing the franchise record book. Taylor has now surpassed Hall of Famer Edgerrin James for the Colts' career rushing-touchdown record with 69 scores.
Perhaps most importantly for fantasy managers, Taylor has twice produced seasons with 20 total touchdowns. That consistency near the goal line demonstrates that his scoring production is not simply the result of one magical season. Taylor possesses the acceleration to break long runs and the instincts to capitalize when Indianapolis reaches the red zone.
2025 dominance
The statistical evidence from 2025 leaves very little room for debate. Taylor handled an NFL-high 323 carries. He turned that massive workload into 1,585 rushing yards and a league-leading 18 rushing touchdowns. He also expanded his role as a receiver, establishing career highs with 46 receptions for 378 yards and two receiving touchdowns.
The result was 20 total touchdowns and 362.3 PPR fantasy football points. That's an extraordinary average of 21.3 points per game. Taylor finished the season as the overall RB4. He once again demonstrated that his fantasy value does not depend on a single scoring format.
2026 projection
His 2026 outlook becomes particularly compelling. Consensus projections call for approximately 327 rushing attempts, 1,510 rushing yards, 13 rushing touchdowns, 45 receptions and 339 receiving yards. That projected production would translate to roughly 312.5 PPR points, 290.0 Half-PPR points and 267.4 standard fantasy football points.
In other words, even with some natural regression from his 20-touchdown campaign, Taylor remains projected as a top-four running back. That is an extraordinary floor. The ceiling, though, is even more enticing.
Taylor does not need to repeat his 2025 touchdown total to justify first-round draft capital. If Indianapolis maintains anything close to last year's workload while keeping him involved in the passing game, he possesses the volume necessary to compete for the overall RB1 crown.
Article Continues Below
Daniel Jones' return
Taylor's contract provides workload security. However, Jones' return provides something equally important: offensive balance. Before his late-season injury in 2025, Jones helped operate Shane Steichen's passing attack efficiently. Now fully cleared and taking first-team reps, Jones gives Indianapolis a legitimate passing threat. He should make it considerably more difficult for defenses to sell out against Taylor.
That relationship could have enormous fantasy football consequences. Running backs thrive when defenses are forced to account for multiple threats. If safeties remain deep because Jones can consistently hit intermediate routes, Taylor gets lighter boxes. If linebackers hesitate because of play-action, Taylor gets cleaner running lanes. Should Indianapolis reach the red zone, Jones' presence as a pocket passer means Taylor can remain the primary beneficiary of the team's rushing opportunities.
That last point is particularly important. Quarterbacks with significant designed rushing responsibilities can occasionally steal valuable goal-line opportunities from their running backs. Jones does not carry that same profile. His presence should allow Taylor to retain a disproportionate share of Indianapolis' most valuable rushing touches.
New contract removes uncertainty
Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor (28) runs the ball against the Atlanta Falcons during the NFL Berlin Game at Olympic Stadium.
Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
There is another reason Taylor's 2026 fantasy outlook deserves attention: the contract itself. A major extension provides clarity regarding how Indianapolis views its offensive centerpiece. The Colts are investing in the player who has repeatedly demonstrated that he can carry their rushing attack.
That matters because workload is king in fantasy football. Explosive efficiency can fluctuate. Touchdowns can regress. Game scripts can change. But players who consistently command enormous workloads give fantasy managers something incredibly valuable: predictability.
Taylor has now demonstrated that he can handle 300-plus carries while remaining productive as a receiver. Indianapolis has every incentive to continue leveraging that versatility, particularly when doing so helps protect Jones and control games. A healthy Taylor therefore enters 2026 with fewer questions surrounding his role than many of the other elite running backs available in the first round.