News of a guilty verdict against Manchester City on 114 of their alleged 115 breaches of the Premier League's financial rules represents only the midpoint of a legal process that still has significant distance to travel, according to new reports.
Could Gianluigi Donnarumma's Manchester City future come under doubt if the club are proven guilty?
More Videos
Friday's news of an independent commission finding Manchester City guilty on 114 of the 115 counts brought against them for alleged financial misconduct across the nine-year period between 2009 and 2018 sent shockwaves across English football.
The findings arrived nearly two years after the independent commission's hearings wrapped up in late 2024, and while the guilty verdict on 114 counts represents a landmark moment in the case, the proceedings are far from over.
Sanctions are still to be determined and Manchester City have signalled their intention to contest the outcome through the appeals process - a path the club have walked before, having successfully overturned a UEFA Champions League ban via the Court of Arbitration for Sport in 2020.
The scale of what Friday's verdict triggered extended well beyond the walls of the Etihad Stadium. Reports emerged within hours that multiple Premier League clubs have been preparing legal action against City, with leading lawyers said to have been mobilised ahead of the verdict in anticipation of the finding.
The basis for those claims rests on the financial losses rival clubs argue they suffered as a direct consequence of City's alleged conduct across the period in question - titles denied, prize money foregone and UEFA Champions League revenue lost on the back of top-four finishes that may not have materialised on a level playing field.
A figure of around £800 million in combined damages has been cited in connection with potential claims from Arsenal, Tottenham, Liverpool and Manchester United.
Inside the City Football Academy on Friday, the atmosphere was one that several people in attendance described as heavy. Staff sought guidance from senior figures within the club on what the verdict meant for the organisation going forward, with concerns about job security among those circulating in the hours after the news broke.
Alongside the anxiety about what comes next, a degree of frustration was also evident - directed in part at former executives who occupied senior positions at the club during the relevant period and who have yet to publicly address the allegations that fall within their tenure.
Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has issued a rare open letter to supporters, reaffirming his "confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence" after an explosive 48 hours in the Premier League's long-running legal battle.cityxtra.co.ukMan City Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak Breaks Silence on 114 Charges Guilty Verdict Reports
Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has issued a rare open letter to supporters, reaffirming his "confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence" after an explosive 48 hours in the Premier League's long-running legal battle.
iPaper Source Says Friday Was "Half-Time" in Man City's Case
As reported by the iPaper, a source at a rival Premier League club described the events of Friday as probably "half-time" in the overall legal battle - a framing that aligns with the broader picture emerging from within the City camp itself.
The club is confident it will ultimately prevail, with senior figures understood to be composed rather than alarmed by the verdict, and the charge that was not proven said to be one of the most serious of the 115 allegations City faced.
Sources cautioning that full resolution of the case may still be two to three years away lend credibility to the rival club source's "half-time" characterisation.
The sanctions phase, whatever it produces, will itself be open to challenge, and the Court of Arbitration for Sport remains available to City as an avenue of appeal - the same route that successfully dismantled the UEFA ban in 2020.
City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak addressed supporters in an open letter on Friday, stating that "the Premier League process still has a long way to run" and that the club's "confidence and intent in proving innocence is just as strong as when this began." He declined to elaborate on the specifics of that confidence, citing the confidentiality obligations that govern the ongoing process.
What Else Has Been Said on Man City's Charges?
The response from current and former Blues added another dimension to a few days that tested the club's public composure. Former City midfielder Rodri, now at Barcelona, has insisted that throughout his seven years at the Etihad Stadium, the club had always communicated their confidence in their own innocence in terms he found credible.
Tottenham's Andy Robertson also came to the defence of the City players themselves, drawing a distinction between the institution facing charges and the footballers who competed for the club with no knowledge of or involvement in alleged financial decisions made at boardroom level.
The "half-time" description from within a rival club reflects what is broadly understood to be the view across the Premier League - that Friday's verdict was a significant development, but that the match is nowhere near finished.
With the sanctions yet to be set, an appeal expected, and a potential wave of civil litigation building in the background, the case that has shadowed English football for more than three years has, in important respects, only just entered its most consequential phase.
The next major procedural step in the legal process will be the sanctions hearing before the independent commission, with the broader appeals and litigation landscape expected to take shape over the months that follow.