A new report has raised serious questions about the Premier League's handling of the disclosure process surrounding Manchester City's guilty verdict on 114 of the alleged 115 financial rule breaches.
Could Elliot Anderson's Manchester City future come under question in the event of a guilty verdict?
More Videos
The independent commission's reported finding that Manchester City breached Premier League financial rules across a nine-year period between 2009 and 2018 has already drawn reaction from across the continent - from La Liga president Javier Tebas, who used it to revisit his nine-year campaign against financial doping, to rival clubs who had mobilised lawyers well before the verdict landed in anticipation of pursuing compensation claims.
The case has now been in train for nearly four years since Manchester City were first charged in February 2023, with hearings before the commission running across a six-week window between September and December 2024.
The circumstances surrounding how that verdict reached the public domain have now come under scrutiny in their own right. While the independent commission delivered its findings and the Premier League has maintained strict confidentiality throughout the process, questions are now being asked about precisely how - and to whom - information about the outcome was first communicated before it entered the public domain last week.
Manchester City, for their part, have stated publicly that the process "remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed." The club is understood to be confident of ultimately winning the argument through the appeals process, drawing in part on the precedent set when they overturned a UEFA Champions League ban at the Court of Arbitration for Sport in 2020.
Sources close to the club have cautioned that full resolution may still be two to three years away, with a rival Premier League club source describing Friday's verdict as merely "half-time" in the overall legal battle.
La Liga president Javier Tebas has used the reports of Manchester City being found guilty on 114 of their alleged 115 Premier League financial rule breaches to revisit his long-running campaign against what he has called financial doping in football.cityxtra.co.ukLa Liga President Tebas Uses Man City Charges to Revisit Nine-Year Battle Against Financial Doping
La Liga president Javier Tebas has used the reports of Manchester City being found guilty on 114 of their alleged 115 Premier League financial rule breaches to revisit his long-running campaign against what he has called financial doping in football.
Club Representatives Said to Have Been Asked to Sign NDAs Before Verdict Briefing
As reported by Telegraph Sport's Sam Wallace, anxiety within the Premier League over how the verdict disclosure process was handled runs well beyond City's own camp.
There are strong indications, Wallace reports, that club representatives from across the top-flight were invited to sign non-disclosure agreements before allegedly being briefed on the commission's findings by the league's senior leadership - understood to include chief executive Richard Masters and chair Alison Brittain.
The implications of that account, if accurate, would mean that representatives of other Premier League clubs were informed of the commission's verdict under conditions of legal confidentiality before the outcome entered the public domain - raising questions about the process through which the league managed that information and the consistency of that approach with its obligations to Manchester City, whose legal representatives have consistently argued for the strict confidentiality of proceedings.
The league's refusal to engage with those questions publicly only deepens the uncertainty around exactly how events unfolded in the days before the verdict became known - as first reported by The Athletic's David Ornstein.
What Has Been the Mood Like at Premier League Clubs Since the News on the Charges Came Out?
The backdrop to those questions is a Premier League that is simultaneously managing the relationship between twenty clubs with profoundly different financial interests in the outcome.
Arsenal, Tottenham, Liverpool and Manchester United are among those who have formally signalled their intention to pursue compensation claims collectively reported to be worth around £800 million, with Tottenham's individual claim understood to be the largest of the group.
That financial exposure means the league is not merely administering an arms-length legal process - it is operating in an environment where its member clubs are active parties in the litigation that flows from it.
Inside the City Football Academy, the mood among non-executive staff has been described as very solemn, with concerns about job security running beneath the composed public posture maintained by the club's leadership.
Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak broke his silence to state that the club's confidence and intent to prove their innocence was as strong as it had been at the outset of proceedings, though reports have also surfaced suggesting doubts are rising among some City staff over whether the appetite to continue fighting will hold if sanctions and civil claims reach severe levels.
Former Manchester City midfielder and current Spain captain Rodri publicly backed the club's innocence on international duty, while Manchester United CEO Omar Berrada - who spent a significant part of the relevant period in a senior operational role at City - has privately distanced himself from any alleged wrongdoing.
Manchester City return to Premier League action on October 11 with a trip to Anfield to face Liverpool, three days before welcoming UEFA Champions League holders Paris Saint-Germain to the Etihad Stadium.
The sanctions hearing before the independent commission represents the next significant legal milestone, with the NDA disclosure questions now adding a further dimension to an already complex set of proceedings.