Senior figures in European football have offered starkly contrasting assessments of Manchester City's reported guilty verdict on 114 of the alleged 115 Premier League financial rule breaches, according to a new report.
Ruben Dias has succeeded Bernardo Silva as Manchester City captain.
More Videos
The independent commission's reported finding that Manchester City breached Premier League financial rules across a nine-year period between 2009 and 2018 arrived on Friday last week after hearings conducted over six weeks between September and December 2024.
The verdict emerged nearly two years after those proceedings concluded - making it the longest and most complex disciplinary case in English football's history.
The five categories of charges against the club covered failures in financial reporting, inadequate disclosure of player and manager compensation, non-compliance with UEFA's financial fair play regulations, profitability and sustainability breaches, and a sustained failure to cooperate with the Premier League's investigation.
Manchester City have consistently denied all 115 allegations and are expected to contest the guilty finding through the appeals process. Senior figures at the club are said to be calm despite the scale of the verdict, with the single unproven charge - reportedly among the most serious of the 115 - understood to be central to the internal belief that they will prevail.
Sources have cautioned that full resolution of the case is not expected until 2028 or 2029 at the earliest, meaning the sanctions phase, the appeals process, and any civil litigation from rival clubs represent a considerable further stretch of proceedings.
Multiple Premier League clubs mobilised legal counsel before the verdict was formally announced, and Arsenal, Tottenham, Liverpool and Manchester United have been among those preparing compensation claims collectively reported to be worth around £800 million, with Tottenham expected to pursue the largest individual figure.
Manchester City are facing the prospect of enormous compensation claims from a group of Premier League rivals, with lawyers braced for the saga to run on far into the future, according to new reports.cityxtra.co.ukMan City Braced for £800M Damages Threat From Premier League Rivals
Manchester City are facing the prospect of enormous compensation claims from a group of Premier League rivals, with lawyers braced for the saga to run on far into the future, according to new reports.
Premier League Rivals Say Man City "Too Powerful" for Lasting Damage; One Calls It "Like Doping"
As reported by The Athletic's Philip Buckingham, a senior figure at a leading European club has described Manchester City as having already accumulated too much power for this case to inflict lasting damage on the organisation.
The view from that quarter is that whatever sanctions ultimately emerge, the structural position City occupy in world football insulates them from the kind of long-term harm the verdict might theoretically threaten.
The picture from within English football is markedly more confrontational. One executive at a Premier League club told Buckingham that Manchester City ought to be stripped of the trophies won across the eight seasons covered by the breaches, drawing a direct comparison with doping in sport: "This is like doping," the source said.
A separate Premier League club executive is said to have described the potential consequences of the verdict as "an absolute disaster," and pushed back against any suggestion that proceedings are approaching their conclusion. In their assessment, the actual end point of this case is not even close.
Those accounts collectively capture the breadth of the reaction that City's guilty finding has generated. Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak broke his public silence following the verdict, insisting the club's conviction in their own innocence remained firm.
What Has Been the Mood Like at Manchester City Since Last Week's Bombshell Revelation?
Inside the City Football Academy, the atmosphere has been different - staff have been reported as anxious about job security amid uncertainty over what the sanctions phase might bring, with doubts surfacing among some employees about the club's capacity to sustain a prolonged legal battle.
The reference to doping made by the Premier League executive echoes the language used publicly by La Liga president Javier Tebas, who used the verdict to revisit his long-running position on what he has called financial doping in European football.
Tebas had been publicly criticised by Manchester City for statements he made at Soccerex in Manchester in 2017, when he first raised concerns about the club's ownership model and sponsorship valuations. The guilty finding on 114 counts has given that argument renewed force in the eyes of those who have long held his position.
The precedent most relevant to how the appeals process might unfold remains Manchester City's successful challenge against UEFA's two-year Champions League ban at the Court of Arbitration for Sport in 2020.
That ruling overturned the ban on the grounds that certain conduct was time-barred and other elements were not proven to the required evidential standard.
City's former midfielder Rodri has publicly backed the club's innocence, citing that precedent directly, while Manchester United CEO Omar Berrada - who served in a senior operational role at City for part of the period in question - has privately distanced himself from any alleged wrongdoing.
The sanctions hearing before the independent commission represents the next significant legal milestone, with the appeals process to follow before any definitive outcome is reached.
Premier League action resumes after the international break with a trip to Liverpool, with Enzo Maresca's side sitting top of the table having won all five of their 2026/27 league fixtures so far.