One weight has been lifted from the Premier League with the publication of the Man City verdict, writes Miguel Delaney, but another has now descended as the sins of a previous era come home to roost, with rival leagues ready to pounce on the damage done
Bookmark popover
Independent Membership
Become an Independent member to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Join today
Already a member? Log in
Your support helps us to tell the story
Read moreSupport Now
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
**Your support makes all the difference.**Read more
In the moments after the Premier League finally published the Manchester City decision, staff at their Brunel Building base could feel a weight lifting. Actually, they could almost hear it.
Some of the most prominent figures were now, finally, able to discuss the case.
For someone like chief executive Richard Masters, it is an extraordinary pressure: to be among the few people on the planet to have knowledge of a case the world was obsessed with. You could almost sense the release in his comments in the Premier League’s statement.
Richard Masters and the Premier League have a fundamental problem following the Man City verdictopen image in gallery
Richard Masters and the Premier League have a fundamental problem following the Man City verdict (Getty)
And yet, as has been the case throughout the eight years of this saga, one development has only opened up another issue; another avenue for complications.
This one is arguably the most fundamental.
The Premier League now has to get on with its raison d’etre of actually playing matches amid the greatest uncertainty it’s ever faced. Worse, we have no idea whether many results will have the same meaning by the end of the season.
There is now huge uncertainty in the Premier League as to whether results will have the same meaning by the end of the seasonopen image in gallery
There is now huge uncertainty in the Premier League as to whether results will have the same meaning by the end of the season (Getty)
This isn’t like after the charges in February 2023, or the initial leaks in November 2018. After those, everything was speculative, just one of many possibilities. Nothing might have happened.
Now, something has finally happened. We have a concrete decision. Manchester City might well overturn this in the appeal process but, right now, they are guilty of charges that are near certain to at least bring significant points deductions.
Almost as relevant as those tangible effects, however, are the emotional effects. Other clubs are furious. Some feel they may struggle to “even be in the same boardroom”.
City and the Premier League nevertheless have to proceed with trying to play games as if everything was normal, but in the most abnormal circumstances.
Man City’s games will likely be played amid farcical scenesopen image in gallery
Man City’s games will likely be played amid farcical scenes (PA)
As one senior source says, “I don’t think people have got their heads around how much of a farce it’s going to be.”
Another who has made significant decisions on regulation adds: “Every game now has an asterisk.”
We will get a profound sense of this in the first weekend back, which also brings a match that may well be the season’s most significant.
The fixture list has always had an amusing capacity for throwing up the most narratively fitting game in the midst of a huge story. And there are none bigger than this.
In the first match back after City have been found guilty of all but one charge in the worst cheating scandal in club football history, they happen to travel to the team who arguably suffered from this most. And, oh, Liverpool are going to let them know it.
Liverpool fans are certain to give Man City both barrels when the teams play a week on Sundayopen image in gallery
Liverpool fans are certain to give Man City both barrels when the teams play a week on Sunday (Getty Images)
The atmosphere at Anfield is going to be febrile. There will surely be banners with the word “sham”. City’s players will by then have reconvened under the club leadership after the international break, but who is to know how they respond.
There might be a siege mentality, but how long can that be sustained amid the certainty of an outcome? It’s not quite like Pep Guardiola being able to say he has faith in the club that the charges will be beaten.
Given how modern football tactics demand intense commitment from players, too, any doubt could eventually cause the team to collapse. It’s why Guardiola himself abruptly discarded players he didn’t feel were fully locked in.
Now, it’s open season.
Pep Guardiola (right) has defended Man Cityopen image in gallery
Pep Guardiola (right) has defended Man City (Reuters)
And an asterisk for so many fixtures in this season only fits with the asterisks that may be required for so many seasons before.
We are talking about an entire era of Premier League history potentially being revised, in a worse manner than the Tour de France or Serie A.
Given the Chelsea case, as well as how everything Manchester City have done since 2018 is inseparable from what they did before 2018 in the nine-year period covered by the investigation, that’s 10 individual titles under question: 2012, 2014, 2015, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024. And that’s even before you get to the rest of the league, with the multiple implications from variables like what Champions League qualification might have done for other clubs.
It just immediately looks so damaging. The very mythos of your competition, what so much of its prestige and spectacle is built on, evaporates. That’s precisely why there is little will to retrospectively strip titles, since you at least keep the semblance of normalcy; that it counted.
It should be stressed that none of this is to make the absurd suggestion the Premier League shouldn’t have taken the case. They absolutely had to, with the need all the greater because of what went before.
This is on Chelsea’s previous ownership and City, pending appeal, but all of that was ultimately facilitated by the lack of regulation that went before – right up to ownership rules.
This is Richard Scudamore’s complicated legacy. Masters’s predecessor may have been crucial to building up the Premier League’s global dominance through his innovation and charismatic deal-making, but the long-term effects of that same governance now pose a threat to that status.
Scudamore’s era was described as “regulation light” and “ownership-model neutral”.
In other words, and in-keeping with New Labour’s approach to foreign investment, anyone was allowed in so long as they didn’t have a criminal conviction. A lot of regulatory issues were sorted out in face-to-face meetings where men would give their word. The Premier League looked like what it was: a club.
That huge foreign investment turbo-charged the league for a long time, but also meant it was going so fast that authorities couldn’t quite keep up.
Man City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak (left) has celebrated plenty of success during his time at the clubopen image in gallery
Man City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak (left) has celebrated plenty of success during his time at the club (PA)
Problems were hard-wired into the system before people even realised they were there. And now, we’re beginning to see the sparks fly, ready to explode.
Many in football have understandably compared it to Calciopoli. That’s both in nature and, more ominously, how that scandal effectively ended Serie A’s decades-long hegemony in 2006. It’s not unfair to say many in foreign leagues have been longing for this moment. This is a chance to rein in the Premier League.
Except, it’s arguably both worse than Calciopoli in terms of scale but nowhere near as bad in terms of effect.
It is obviously damaging, and a considerable threat. The crucial sense that you can completely trust what you see on the pitch has already been eroded. It was only earlier this year, however, that LaLiga’s Javier Tebas was talking about how the Premier League was too far ahead to ever be caught.
LaLiga president Javier Tebas will hope his league is ready to capitalise on any reputational damage to the Premier Leagueopen image in gallery
LaLiga president Javier Tebas will hope his league is ready to capitalise on any reputational damage to the Premier League (Reuters)
There might well have been an element of calculation to those comments, but the numbers also illustrate he’s right. A global cultural dominance has crucially been established in the first years of truly global media. That’s quite a head start.
Regardless of what happens with City, too, some fundamentals will remain.
This is unpopular to say amid so much talk of a “red cartel” but acres of academic research – most notably from the University of Liverpool’s David Forrest – show that the Premier League only really needs Manchester United, Liverpool and Arsenal to definitely be in it, as well the possibility that they can frequently be beaten by the other 17; in other words, those big names and a sense that there’s competitiveness and unpredictability.
City, for all their success in this disputed era, have never really moved the dial in that sense. And yet they may shake the Premier League in a manner that has every other league hoping to pick up the pieces.
Despite their success, Man City have never truly moved the dial globallyopen image in gallery
Despite their success, Man City have never truly moved the dial globally (Getty Images)
Wednesday alone saw an Abu Dhabi state-owned airline threaten legal action and the prime minister make some curious comments about the case, and the ownership.
It only emphasises the mess of all of this, a direct consequence of that Scudamore era. A weight has lifted. Another problem descends.