liverpoolecho.co.uk

How every Premier League table looks with Man City results void as Liverpool and Everton wronged

Liverpool's English midfielder Steven Gerrard (C) applauds after the English Premier League football match between Liverpool and Everton at the Anfield stadium in Liverpool, northwest England, on January 28, 2014. Liverpool won 4-0. AFP PHOTO / PAUL ELLISRESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or "live" services. Online in-match use limited to 45 images, no video emulation. No use in betting, games or single club/league/player publications. (Photo by PAUL ELLIS / AFP via Getty Images)

Liverpool's English midfielder Steven Gerrard (C) applauds after the English Premier League football match between Liverpool and Everton at the Anfield stadium in Liverpool, northwest England, on January 28, 2014. Liverpool won 4-0. AFP PHOTO / PAUL ELLISRESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or "live" services. Online in-match use limited to 45 images, no video emulation. No use in betting, games or single club/league/player publications. (Photo by PAUL ELLIS / AFP via Getty Images)

View 3 Images

Things could have been very different for Everton and Liverpool(Image: PAUL ELLIS, AFP via Getty Images)

The repercussions of Manchester City being found guilty of the bulk of their Premier League charges continue to be felt deeply across the football world.

However it is only now, as we look at hypothetical alternative tables, that we see exactly how significantly Everton and Liverpool were impacted. City have been found guilty of more than 100 charges, many relating to financial rule breaches, relating to the 2009-18 period.

The multiple league champions, who continue to strongly maintain their innocence, were cleared on one count concerning non-cooperation with the investigation, which was carried out by an independent commission They said they are "disappointed and surprised" by the ruling.

The Manchester club won three Premier League titles during the period in question, under three different managers. While the sanctions have yet to be determined, the clubs who finished as runners-up in the seasons in question will no doubt be wondering what could have been, as will those who finished behind City and narrowly missed out on European spots.

READ MORE: Man City 'sham' denied Jurgen Klopp his true Liverpool legacy - but his day is coming

Liverpool and Everton are, of course, among those clubs impacted. Most notably, the Reds finished second behind City in the 2013/14 title race and their neighbours were just outside the top four in the same campaign.

2009/10 Premier League

1. Chelsea 86

2. Man Utd 85

3. Arsenal 74

4. Tottenham 64

5. Aston Villa 63

6. Liverpool 61

7. Everton 55

8. Blackburn 50

9. Birmingham 49

10. Stoke 46

11. Fulham 45

12. Sunderland 43

13. Bolton 38

14. Wolves 37

15. West Ham 35

16. Wigan 33

17. Burnley 29

18. Hull 26

19. Portsmouth 19

20. Man City 0

Several prominent figures have called for serious punishment, with former Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn among those launching calls for City to be stripped of those titles, relegated and subjected to substantial fines. Voiding City's results produces fascinating revised Premier League tables that illustrate how things could have been different for Merseyside's two Premier League clubs.

2010/11 Premier League

1. Man Utd 76

2. Chelsea 68

3. Arsenal 64

4. Tottenham 61

5. Liverpool 55

6. Everton 48

7. Fulham 48

8. West Brom 47

9. Newcastle 46

10. Stoke 45

11. Bolton 45

12. Aston Villa 45

13. Sunderland 44

14. Blackburn 42

15. Wigan 42

16. Blackpool 39

17. Wolves 37

18. Birmingham 37

19. West Ham 33

20. Man City 0

In the first two seasons concerned, neither Liverpool nor Everton were challenging right at the top of the table. However, removing City's results would see the Blues qualify for Europe in 2010 and the Reds sneak up to seventh 12 months after that.

2011/12 Premier League

1. Man Utd 89

2. Tottenham 69

3. Arsenal 67

4. Newcastle 65

5. Chelsea 61

6. Everton 53

7. Liverpool 51

8. Fulham 51

9. Norwich 47

10. West Brom 46

11. Swansea 44

12. Stoke 44

13. Wigan 43

14. Sunderland 41

15. Aston Villa 38

16. QPR 37

17. Bolton 36

18. Blackburn 31

19. Wolves 25

20. Man City 0

Curiously, removing City's results in 2012/13 would see Liverpool overtake Everton and claim a European berth. This is because Everton took four points off the league runners-up, compared to Liverpool's two.

2012/13 Premier League

1. Man Utd 86

2. Chelsea 74

3. Arsenal 72

4. Tottenham 69

5. Liverpool 59

6. Everton 59

7. West Brom 49

8. Swansea 45

9. West Ham 45

10. Fulham 43

11. Stoke 41

12. Aston Villa 41

13. Newcastle 41

14. Norwich 41

15. Southampton 38

16. Sunderland 36

17. Wigan 36

18. Reading 28

19. QPR 24

20. Man City 0

The season after that is the big one, though. Not only would Liverpool be crowned champions in the alternate table, but their neighbours would qualify for the Champions League.

Liverpool players celebrate against Manchester City in 2014

Liverpool would be 2013/14 Premier League champions in the alternate reality(Image: Liverpool FC via Getty Images)

View 3 Images

2013/14 Premier League

1. Liverpool 81

2. Arsenal 78

3. Chelsea 76

4. Everton 72

5. Tottenham 69

6. Man Utd 64

7. Southampton 55

8. Stoke 49

9. Newcastle 49

10. Crystal Palace 45

11. Swansea 42

12. West Ham 40

13. Hull 37

14. West Brom 36

15. Aston Villa 35

16. Sunderland 34

17. Norwich 32

18. Fulham 32

19. Cardiff 27

20. Man City 0

That painful final day, with Liverpool denied top spot by City, would no longer be a factor. What's more, a seat at European football's top table would be the reward for Roberto Martinez delivering Everton's best ever Premier League points tally.

2014/15 Premier League

1. Chelsea 85

2. Arsenal 71

3. Man Utd 67

4. Tottenham 64

5. Southampton 60

6. Liverpool 59

7. Swansea 56

8. Stoke 51

9. Everton 46

10. Crystal Palace 45

11. West Ham 44

12. West Brom 44

13. Leicester 41

14. Newcastle 39

15. Sunderland 38

16. Aston Villa 38

17. Hull 34

18. Burnley 29

19. QPR 29

20. Man City 0

Moving on to 2015/16, removing CIty's results would give Jurgen Klopp a Europa League spot in his first season at Anfield. There's little notable change for the Merseyside clubs one year either side of that, though things would be different in the final season affected by City's charges.

2015/16 Premier League

1. Leicester 77

2. Arsenal 67

3. Tottenham 64

4. Man Utd 62

5. Southampton 60

6. West Ham 58

7. Liverpool 54

8. Chelsea 50

9. Stoke 48

10. Swansea 46

11. Everton 45

12. Watford 45

13. West Brom 43

14. Crystal Palace 42

15. Bournemouth 42

16. Sunderland 39

17. Newcastle 36

18. Norwich 33

19. Aston Villa 16

20. Man City 0

Everton finished one place outside the European spots in 2017/18, with Burnley progressing to the Europa League qualifying rounds in their stead. Without City, they'd get yet more European football while Liverpool would also climb a spot to third.

Everton players celebrating in 2018

Everton would have more European campaigns if City's results were null and void(Image: Getty Images)

View 3 Images

2016/17 Premier League

1. Chelsea 87

2. Tottenham 82

3. Arsenal 74

4. Liverpool 72

5. Man Utd 68

6. Everton 57

7. Bournemouth 46

8. West Brom 45

9. Southampton 45

10. West Ham 45

11. Stoke 43

12. Crystal Palace 41

13. Leicester 41

14. Swansea 41

15. Burnley 40

16. Watford 40

17. Hull 34

18. Middlesbrough 26

19. Sunderland 24

20. Man City 0

As you can see, removing City's results could have led to more European football for both Everton and Liverpool. However, there's no change as big as that in the 2013/14 campaign, which would have seen Liverpool crowned champions some six years before they finally broke their Premier League duck for good.

2017/18 Premier League

1. Man Utd 78

2. Tottenham 77

3. Liverpool 72

4. Chelsea 70

5. Arsenal 63

6. Burnley 53

7. Everton 48

8. Leicester 47

9. Newcastle 44

10. Bournemouth 44

11. Crystal Palace 43

12. West Ham 42

13. Watford 41

14. Brighton 40

15. Huddersfield 36

16. Southampton 36

17. Swansea 33

18. Stoke 33

19. West Brom 31

20. Man City 0

Of course, the Premier League wasn't the only competition in which City competed between 2009 and 2018. City beat Liverpool in the 2016 League Cup final, denying title-winning manager Klopp what might have been a first trophy at the club.

Everton were denied by City in the very same competition, losing 4-3 on aggregate in the semi-finals. We can only speculate as to what might have been different in that nine-year period but for now it's time to wait and see how all of this is resolved.

Read full news in source page