Everton manager David Moyes.
Photo by Maynard Manyowa/News Images/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Jack Grealish playing for Everton.
Photo by Andrew Kearns – CameraSport via Getty Images
Newcastle United v Everton - Premier League 2026/27
Photo by Molly Darlington/Getty Images
Jack Grealish playing for Everton.
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images
Everton veteran Seamus Coleman.
Photo by Lewis Storey/Getty Images
Newcastle United v Everton - Premier League 2026/27
Photo by George Wood/Getty Images
Newcastle United v Everton - Premier League 2026/27
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images
Everton vs Newcastle player ratings, Thierno Barry scores but 8.5/10 star was real MVP
Thierno Barry celebrates for Everton - Premier League 2026/27
Photo by Ben Roberts – Danehouse/Getty Images
Everton made it back-to-back wins over Newcastle with a massive victory at St. James’ Park.
Everything is looking peachy for David Moyes right now as he guided Everton to another win over Newcastle in the Premier League on Monday night, days after the 3-1 victory in the cup.
It was a brilliant performance. Here are Everton’s player ratings from the 1-0 win.
What a week 😍 Everton beat Newcastle AGAIN – give us your reaction 👇
😂
He needs to work on his whole game. If he hasn't developed a decent first touch, holding up the ball, winning headers at 24 yrs old, it would be a miracle if he becomes a top rate player.
Jordan Pickford – 8
One of the easier nights at St James’ Park for the Everton keeper. He must have loved every minute of this win. Some huge contributions toward the end of the game.
Jake O’Brien – 7
Slightly out of position, but he did really well in all areas of the pitch. Might have nabbed the position from Merlin Rohl with this display.
James Tarkowski – 7
Like a fine wine, Tarkowski continues to improve with age. Another top showing here as he handled Newcastle’s attack with relative comfort.
Jarrad Branthwaite – 8.5
Stellar performance from a Rolls-Royce defender. Back to his very best, completely dominant aerially for Everton against Newcastle. A huge showing, what a player he is.
Vitaliy Mykolenko – 7
Really good performance from Everton’s often unsung star. Defended excellently and did well with the ball as well. He is really growing as a player this season.
Harrison Armstrong – 7
While he didn’t quite have the impact that Hayden Hackney did last week, it was a good performance from Armstrong. Looked right at home.
James Garner – 7.5
Another outstanding display in midfield, running the show, and again outclassing Newcastle’s more expensive duo. Quickly becoming one of the best in the league.
Merlin Rohl – 7
Not a natural fit in attacking positions, and he stuck out like a sore thumb in the front four, but his pace was a blessing for Moyes. He offered a great deal in nullifying Newcastle.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall – 8
Another superb showing by Everton’s main man as he created two big chances. Looked excellent, carrying play forward well; he is the talisman behind this winning streak the Toffees are now on.
Tyrique George – 7
Created the goal for Barry, and looked dangerous every time he was on the ball. His end product just didn’t match up to the promising signs.
Thierno Barry – 7.5
Another goal for Barry sees him hit 10 goal contributions this season in just 12 games. He won’t get much credit for the finish, considering he was a yard out, but all-around, the performance was strong. Turning into a top-class number nine.
Brennan Johnson – 6.5
Worked hard after coming off the bench to help see out the win.
Michael Keane – 6.5
Did well after replacing Branthwaite, helped see out the win.
Hayden Hackney – 6.5
Not enough minutes.