manchestereveningnews.co.uk

Enzo Fernandez is not quite adding up after Man City record transfer

Enzo Maresca, Manchester City players and sponsors already love Enzo Fernandez, but some supporters just aren't having him

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 05: Enzo Fernandez of Manchester City during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Manchester City and Coventry City at Etihad Stadium on September 05, 2026 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Naomi Baker/Getty Images)

Manchester City midfielder Enzo Fernandez

View Image

All eyes will be on Elliot Anderson when he returns to Nottingham Forest on Saturday following his £116m transfer to Manchester City. Anderson, though, only spent a few weeks as the club's record signing before Enzo Fernandez arrived for £125m - and some Blues think that things simply don't add up with that deal.

Fernandez has long been a divisive figure in football, the sort of player that is loved by supporters of his own team as much as he is loathed by fans of opposition clubs. It has been quite the year for him in that regard, suspended by Chelsea after publicly criticising the departure of Enzo Maresca and booed by some of his own fans when he was about to seal a reunion with his former manager at City.

Between those points, Fernandez smashed dangerously into Anderson in the opening minutes of the World Cup semi-final, scored a vital equaliser, celebrated provocatively, and then enjoyed a social media video of those celebrations that was set to the England anthem for the tournament Wonderwall.

Fernandez will always antagonise wherever he goes because it is part of his identity, and it's fair to say plenty of City fans were thrilled for him to become the new record signing. It was necessary to back Maresca in a window where they had lost both Rodri and Bernardo Silva, yet anyone was going to compare unfavourably to those two legends.

That said, there was plenty of excitement for Fernandez inside the walls of the City Football Academy. Maresca had hardly been able to contain a smile when the player was mentioned for weeks and in the days before deadline day several players came up to him to ask for the latest.

City's sponsors were also licking their lips. Sergio Aguero and, to a lesser extent, Julian Alvarez were important markers for selling City to the enormous South American audience and World Cup winner Fernandez re-opens those doors for commercial opportunities; shirt sales have been strong and in the new City store at the ground 'Enzo' is one of four names plastered on the back of shirts on display alongside Foden, Cherki, and Haaland.

Fernandez is undeniably one of the most high-profile footballers in the game, and City rushed through his medical in the final hours of deadline day to complete his signing. In addition to City's army of photographers and videographers, there was an extra content team documenting the midfielder's arrival as he greeted Hugo Viana before speaking to Ferran Soriano on the phone.

For all the hype, there has been a shyness and sense of duty in the way Fernandez has started at the Etihad. He answered an emergency call to make his debut against Coventry when Nico O'Reilly got injured in the warm-up, and has needed to be pushed by teammates into taking acclaim from the away support on two separate occasions.

You wouldn't know that from his online persona though, with pictures shared on his accounts from City's win at Anfield showing him celebrating in the face of marked hostility from Liverpool fans. City matchgoing supporters quickly adopted his chant - 'In your head' to Zombie, by The Cranberries - and his qualities go beyond what is visible on the pitch, according to coaches.

"He's a world champion, he has great qualities, not only in ball possession but also he's a leader," said RB Leipzig coach Martin Demichelis this week. "He has great character. His personality is really special so I'm pretty convinced that Enzo Maresca, with the experience that he has and had with him at Chelsea, knows he's aware of his qualities obviously as a leader and with his aggression and mentality."

Fernandez scored his second goal for City to help them beat Demichelis's side 3-2 in midweek and continue a strong start to the season, but not everyone was happy. A small but vocal section of supporters online were furious that he had kept his place in the team after his worst two performances of the season came against Villa and Brighton, and even many mild-mannered fans are struggling to see how he warrants his price tag - in a way that nobody is about Anderson.

Being labelled as a winner doesn't really help when the team loses, and Fernandez's previous with Maresca means their fates are tied: if there is a problem with one, it must reflect poorly on the other. To say he was brought in as the player who knows Maresca's football best, the midfield has looked increasingly muddled in recent weeks and Fernandez has been a constant in that with the spaces he has been taking up meaning his defensive work is limited yet he is not contributing significantly to the attack.

Make sure you never miss the latest Manchester City news and opinion by making Manchester Evening News one of your Google preferred sources.

Having overseen his transition from a defensive player to a goalscoring midfielder, Maresca needs his man to start stepping up and goals may be the currency that see him buy the favour of more supporters. Without them, what he offers on the pitch is under suitable scrutiny - especially given the way lots of fans have taken to Moroccan youngster Ayyoub Bouaddi to the extent that some of the more extreme fans have taken Fernandez's mere presence on a teamsheet as an attack on one of their favourite players.

If that anger reached new levels in midweek, the away end in Leipzig featured a banner dedicated to the 25-year-old and Phil Foden pushed him closer to it at full-time as City celebrated their victory. With the game in the balance at half-time, despite not being a captain Fernandez had been going round the players in the tunnel as they waited to go out trying to get a message across.

Fernandez is already loved by Maresca, his new teammates and club sponsors, as well as respected by opposition managers and cheered by a big chunk of City supporters. That does not mean he should be undroppable though, and there are also plenty of Blues that are expecting more from the record signing.

While his reputation is as a divisive figure, Fernandez is splitting opinion at City more than even he would probably want.

Read full news in source page