Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta claps with Farai Hallam inset
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta claps with Farai Hallam inset
Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty when Kai Havertz was fouled in the first half of Saturday's 1-0 win over Hull City.
That is the opinion of former head of PGMOL and FIFA referee, Keith Hackett, speaking exclusively to Football Insider.
Martin Odegaard's second-half strike secured the three points for the home side, but much of the post-game discussion has been dominated by the moment.
Farai Hallam had initially missed the shirt pull on Havertz, with VAR Michael Oliver eventually asking him to stop the game and go to the monitor.
There, it was clear that the German had been fouled by Nobel Mendy, but that the striker was in an offside position when the action took place.
Hallam's voice was met with cheers from the home side when he announced that Havertz had been fouled, but joy was quickly replaced by bemusement when he awarded an indirect free-kick to Hull for the offside.
Former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann explains why Arsenal should have been awarded penalty against Hull for a foul on Kai Havertz 🗣💬 pic.twitter.com/9J6Npjde1O
— Match of the Day (@BBCMOTD) November 8, 2026
'The correct outcome would've been...'
The question on the minds of most after Hallam's announcement was why was he sent to the monitor in the first place?
If Oliver already knew Havertz was offside, he surely should have dismissed the incident completely.
Hackett shared a similar sentiment, but closer inspection of the rules since has revealed that a different outcome should have taken place.
"I have now had the opportunity to revisit the law with regard to the holding offence in the penalty area where the officials took some time to rule out the award of a penalty kick in favour of offside," he told Football Insider.
"Here is the law: If a player in an offside position is moving towards the ball with the intention of playing the ball and is fouled before playing or attempting to play the ball, or challenging an opponent for the ball, the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence.
"So the correct outcome would have been to award the penalty kick. I cannot recall an incident that this aspect of law has come into play.
"That is why referee Hallam and VAR Michael Oliver got it wrong."
Is the rule fit for purpose?
While the rule suggests that the referees got it wrong on Saturday, it also prompts another discussion.
Havertz may not have been challenging for the ball, but he was certainly attempting to make a movement towards it.
Mengi's pull of his shirt was not clearly not a completely random decision, the defender was preventing him from running towards the ball.
With that in mind, it seems bizarre that the fact that the striker was offside should not impact the decision. This is a rule that perhaps could benefit from review.